Melbourne, Australia — The International Cricket Council (ICC) has handed a rare and striking verdict against the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG), rating the pitch as “unsatisfactory” after the fourth Test of the Ashes series between Australia and England concluded in just two days. The rating, one of the lowest in the ICC’s four-tier Pitch and Outfield Monitoring Process, has sent shockwaves through the cricketing world, raising questions about pitch preparation and the integrity of the iconic Test venue.
The two-day finish stunned fans worldwide, as England secured a four-wicket victory with astonishing speed. Across just six sessions, 36 wickets fell, and not a single batter reached a half-century, an extraordinary outcome for a ground renowned for its balanced pitches and historic five-day contests. Match referee Jeff Crowe stated that the pitch “was too much in favour of the bowlers,” noting that the extreme conditions deviated sharply from ICC expectations for a fair Test surface.
As a result of the rating, the MCG has been assigned one demerit point, which will remain on the venue’s record for five years. Under ICC regulations, accumulating six demerit points within five years could lead to a 12-month suspension from hosting international matches, putting future high-profile fixtures at risk if pitch standards are not improved.
The ICC’s decision has sparked debate among cricket analysts, players, and fans. Traditionally considered one of Australia’s premier Test venues, the MCG had maintained a strong record of positive pitch ratings over recent years. The “unsatisfactory” tag not only breaks that trend but also reignites discussions about player safety, competitive balance, and the financial implications of matches concluding much earlier than anticipated.
Cricket Australia now faces scrutiny over the preparation of the pitch, with questions emerging about whether the ground staff were able to provide a surface suitable for a five-day contest. The early finish also affected match-day attendance, broadcast schedules, and fan experience, highlighting the commercial as well as sporting stakes involved in hosting marquee events like the Boxing Day Test.
As the Ashes series moves to Sydney for the final match, all eyes will be on how venues adapt to ICC standards, manage player feedback, and meet fan expectations. The MCG’s latest rating serves as a reminder of the delicate balance required in cricket between tradition, competition, and safety, and underscores the challenges faced by ground staff in preparing surfaces that live up to the sport’s highest standards.
This story has been reported by PakTribune. All rights reserved.