Pakistan News Service

Monday Nov 20, 2017, Rabi-al-awwal 1, 1439 Hijri
Logo Logo
LATEST :
Pakistan News Home -> Speakouts -> Speakout

The Mumbai Massacre : Who? How? Why?

04 December, 2008

  Related News  
Delhi behind parliament attack, 26/11: ex-officer
'Hindu terrorism' in India is a fact: Salman Khurshid
  Related Articles  
Hindu terrorism exposed
By Asif Haroon Raja
Is India Behind Mumbai and Lok Sabha Attacks?
By Zaheerul Hassan
  Related Speakout  
  More on this View All
  Related News Poll

A heinous crime has taken place in Mumbai. Innocent human beings have been killed by some monsters in the name of some dubious causes. Pakistan Tribune shares the grief of the victims and offers heartfelt condolences to the aggrieved.


At the moment there are a lot of conflicting reports coming out of the India. There is a crossfire of blames and counter-blames between India and Pakistan. Intense emotional rhetoric is further fogging up the already murky situation enveloping the two nuclear armed states. It is time to cool it off, troubleshoot and, if possible, nip the evil in the bud to avoid a repeat of the incident on either side.


Despite having immense internal problems, starting from Kashmir and spreading as far away as Nagaland and Assam, India feels that the roots of all her troubles lie in Pakistan. While Pakistan, a country most violently hit by terrorism, which has lost thousands of its citizens to terrorism and whose President’s wife was assassinated by similar criminals, feels that India is being unjust in its accusations and that both countries are victims of the same criminals who do not wish to see the two neighbors supping at the same table.


Pakistanis further say that there are also Islamist terror camps in Bangladesh, where the 10,000 strong JMB group receives ample funding and arms from sympathizers across the Muslim world. And that even in India, a massive country with large rural areas under-patrolled by police, Islamist terrorist camps have been found in the Karnataka jungles of the Southwest. What is more, the Maoist Naxalite movement operates in thirteen of India’s twenty-six states and is a robust organization with anywhere up to 20,000 members. In April 2006, Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh himself called the Naxalite threat the “biggest internal security challenge ever faced by our country.” The Pakistanis assert that there’s plenty of indigenous terrorist training capacity, not all of it controlled by or even backed by Pakistan. And that the insurgency in the North of Pakistan is being fueled and funded by Indians through their Consulates from across the border in Afghanistan.



  • Who did it, how they did it, why they did it and what is the solution? Speak out.
  • Reader Comments:

    Who? How? Why?

    Every crime has its reasons with perpetrator's interests hidden behind it. A sincere and thoughtful analysis can unearth the real culprits of Mumbai massacre and in this case it is evident like day-light that, apart from the innocent lives lost, Pakistan is the next hardest hit casualty. It is on the brink of losing almost every thing it painfully built in its struggle to establish a soft image of responsible and peaceful country interested in welfare of its people and also the world at large. There are several reasons to explain that, Pakistan has only to lose and nothing to gain from this heinous crime against humanity committed by the perpetrators carnage that I tend to ruefully call Mumbai holocaust:



    Present democratic Government of Pakistan has a very deep rooted vested interest involved in playing safe with India, as well as not giving its armed forces to be draged into any disgraceful compromises. Ever since assuming their democratic responsibilities as President and Prime Minister of the world's 5th largest country, President Zardari and PM Gilani have repeatedly expressed their sincere and firm resolve to have truly cordial and mutually respectful friendly relations with India for the wellbeing of their respective people. Even Nawaz Sharif has taken no time in expressing his desire to pick up the strings of friendship which he established during his stewardship and strongly re-bind them to extend further, leading to a logical conclusion.



    Pakistan Army has also realized that, martial tactics have bitterly failed in all of its initiatives to date in producing results in any endeavours. Therefore, it must assume a humane role and spend its energies in fighting vices and extending humanity, rather than fighting savage wars for generations spending hard earned money of depressed people without fruitful results. Accordingly, it has assumed the role of a strong and highly professional anti-terror work force more tuned to the world expectations than any senseless skirmishes for unfounded reasons with India.





    It is unfortunate that, some fortune hunting politicians of India are desperate in kneeling and begging favours from America for their person reasons. India should remember that, Rice only talked what she had been fed by American “Intelligence Think-Tank". Not long ago, Goldman Sachs, an American “Economic Think-Tank" had predicted India to be the third largest economy of the world in next 20 years. Getting the cue, Bush had asked Americans not “to respond to its (India's) exploding economy, by erecting Economic Barriers", which is a clear indication of hidden intentions. So let us erect our own think-tank defense and read the message.

    I tend to advise India. "Stop thumping chests, as your ancient civilization were ruined before and history is being repeated." Remember what became of the Leaping Asian Tigers of Nineties. Also remember that Millennium watchers had warned that, by 2050, South Korea would be leading the world by far, with a per-capita income exceeding a whopping one million US Dollars!----- unless BRAKES were APPLIED!

    As a multi-ethnic, multi-religious democracy, India is showing the world that the best way to ensure fairness and tolerance is, to establish the rule of law. The best way to counter resentment is to allow peaceful expression. The best way to honor human dignity is to protect human rights. For every nation divided by race, religion or culture, India should offer a hopeful path: If justice is the goal, then democracy is the only way. For this, a continuously conducive atmosphere is a prerequisite which can only be achieved with a prosperous, democratic Pakistan as India steadfast partner in progress in addition to being its peaceful neighbour.



    M.Saeed, Pakistan - 14 December, 2008

    FALSE HOOD

    Be a good human being then only u can call ur self a good musalman or a hindu.....

    Ashwani TANDON, Hungary - 15 December, 2008

    Still you have time

    Guyz, pl for haven's sake, wake up, this kind of activity will lead you no-where. Realise, Life is really beautiful. Enjoy it. Give time to your Family, Girl friend, relative, your loved ones. Why, the thinking is to make all the world, Muslim..learn good from others, enjoy cross-cultur. Above all LOVE YOUR GOD and OTHER'S too.

    Sunil, Hungary - 15 December, 2008

    Love peace and justice

    Who and How's become shadow players of Why's when there are numerous injustices against the weak and the small and the oppressed. Still,terror of any body or from any body must be checked and stopped.And if the weak as culprits are condemned or even punished, the strong ones need at least condoning of their wrong doings.

    The Paks may have even tolerated it as poison pill about the suicidal bombings and kind of financed terror and it is great forgiveness by Paks even when they have mountain of proof about who did it.President Musharraf even presented that proof to the Americans.And the Kashmiris are living as psychologically battered with all types of human rights abuses of rape and molesting.Instead of condemning these violations, Indians are priding in international forums with brags and pleasures over such inhumane acts.

    Sad tragedies come out of injustices,and injustice against one innocent people is just as bad as injustices against the others.

    What is required for all of south Asia is an auditted study of hate levels.My auditing shows that hindus of India have excelled in hate levels by a margin of 8 to 1 and still no sane person will agree to or approve even other one eigth hate of the oppressed minority people.

    ALL PEOPLE OF SOUTH ASIA-I MEAN HINDUS,MUSLIMS HAVE TO ELIMINATE THIS HATE AND RESPECT EACH OTHER ON EQUAL LEVELS BESIDES.AND VIOLENCE HAS TO BE ROOTED OUT.

    THE BLOOD OF INOCENTS IN BOMBAY NEEDS AS MUCH CRYING CAUSE AS THE MOLESTATION AND KILLINGS OF PRETTY AND HANDSOME KASHMIRI PEOPLE.PAKISTAN AS A COUNTRY OR PEOPLE HAVE NO ROLE IN THESE TRAGEDIES,EVEN WHEN SOME INDIANS ARE PRIDING OVER RAPING AND KILLING OF KASHMIRI WOMEN IN INTERNATIONAL FORUMS.SOUTH ASIANS WILL HAVE PERFECT AND NORMAL PEACE WHEN ALL IN SOUTH ASIA-IN INDIA AND PAKISTAN REMOVE HATE FROM THEIR HEARTS AND IT IS SAD TO READ SOME THREATENING SOME BODY'S LIFE ON SIMPLE SMALL EXCUSE OF SIMPLE JOURNALISM.

    YOU CAN EVEN DELAY OR HOLD IN ABAYANCE OR EVEN DO PACIFYING MASSAGE ON POLITICAL ISSUES LIKE SOLVING KASHMIR PROBLEM OR WHATEVER.AS LOVING EACH OTHER MEMBERS OF THE SAME LOVING FAMILY, YOU CAN ALLWAYS KISS THE ANGER AWAY AND WAIT FOR THE BETTER, LET ALONE KILLING THE FELLOW BROTHER.

    LOVE AND RESPECT OF THE OTHER RELIGIONS AS WELL AS ETHNICITIES IS THE ONLY THING THAT CAN BRING PEACE TO SOUTH ASIA.OTHERWISE,TRY THE NUCLEAR WAR AND THERE WILL BE NOTHING LEFT OUT THERE.DO NOT FORGET THAT BESIDES THE COMPARABLE NUCLEAR WEAPONORY OF ENOUGH ANNIHILATION SIZES, THE BIGGEST RADIATION KILLING FACTOR DOES NOT FAVOUR INDIA AT ALL AND POOR BANGLADESH MAY GO ALONG WITH OTHERS DUE TO THE RADIATION CAUSED BIGGEST KILL FACTOR AS ALL WINDS TRAVEL AWAY FROM PAKISTAN.THIS WAS AT LEAST THE ASSESSMENT DONE BY THE AMERICANS AND OTHER THINK TANKS ON THE EVE OF 1998 NUCLEAR TESTS BY BOTH INDIA AND PAKISTAN.

    YOU DO NOT KILL PEOPLE WHEN YOU ACCOMODATE THE FELLOW HUMAN OF ANY RACE AND COLOUR.THERE MUST BE NEED, BEAUTY AND WANT OF EVERY HUMAN REGARDLESS OF ANY COLOUR OR RELIGION OR RACE.

    NO SENSIBLE PERSON WILL POINT HIS BLAME FINGER ON PAKS, GIVEN THE STRESS OF ALL THE MIGHTIEST NATIONS TRYING TO ESTABLISH THEIR WORLD SIZE AND WORLD CLASS FRONT LINES OF DEFENCES IN THE NAME OF TERROR OR WHATEVER.THE POOR LITTLE PAKS DO NOT AGREE TO THE MIGHTY ONES IF IT INVOLVES NOTHING LESS THAN CAMBODIA, LAOS TYPE GENOCIDES AS FUTURE RESULTS,AND THEN THEY ARE MADE NON-AGREEING TARGETS.THEN THE PRETTY KASHMIRAS GET RAPED AND SOME ONE OPENLY BOASTS ABOUT THAT ON INTERNATIONAL FORUMS.ANY UGLY THINGS CAN DEVELOPE OUT OF INJUSTICES EVEN THOUGH PAK PEOPLE AND NATION ARE NOT ACCOMPLICES.DO NOT GO OUTSIDE,THE UNTOUCHABLES OF INDIA GO THROUGH SIMILAR INJUSTICES IF THEY TURN TO CHRISTIANITY WITH SANGUINE FUTURE THAT MOST OF UNTOUCHABLE INDIA WILL BE SEEKING PROTECTION OF CHRISTIANITY BY CONVERTING INTO AND BECOMING STRONG FROM WEAK.THE UN-TOUCHABLES DO NOT FEEL AS MUCH PROTECTION IN WEAK MUSLIMS AS WITH STRONG CHRISTIANITY.

    I AM NOT A RABBLE ROUSER, BUT I HAVE PERSONALLY HEARD BIG HATE AGAINST 200 MILLION UNTOUCHABLES AND SOMEWHAT LESS HATE AGAINST OTHER LOWER YET HIGHER THAN THE UNTOUCHABLE PEOPLE.

    PAKISTAN ITSELF IS TOO SMALL AND YET TOO STRESSED FOR ITS SIZE BY JUST ABOUT EVERY BODY'S POWER AGENDAS.KASHMIRIS GET GRINDED IN THE EAST AND PAKS ARE BLAMED FOR ANY THING OR EVERY THING.AND THEN PATHANS GET SIMILAR FATE AND PAKS ARE TOLD TO BEAR IT ALL EVEN IF IT HAS TO GO THROUGH MILLIONS MASSACRE IN THE NWFP AND TRIBAL AREAS.AND THEN THE PROBLEMS GET COMPOUNDED AND COMPILED WHEN SOME ONE STARTS THE FINANCING OF BALOCHIS AND SUICIDAL BOMBINGS.POOR PAKISTAN AND ITS PEOPLE ARE NOT AT FAULT AND THE ONLY THING THAT IS SAVING THE NATION IS THEIR FAIR SIZE NUCLEAR ARSENAL AS ANY NUCLEAR EXCHANGE WILL ANNIHILATE ALL OF SOUTH ASIA.

    SO LOVE YOUR FELLOW HINDU AND FELLOW MUSLIM AND FELLOW SIKH AND FELLOW CHRISTIAN OR FELLOW ANY BODY ELSE AND TREAT HIM WITH RESPECT OF EQUALITY WITH VALUED LOOKS ON HIS LIFE.

    ONLY PEACE,LOVE AND JUSTICE WILL SAVE SOUTH ASIA.

    Anwar Mahmood, Canada - 15 December, 2008

    Good that Pakis are realising

    Only way forward for Pakistan if it wants country to prosper is to stop these mullah`s from running the show. It is high time people of Pakistan should rise above India Vs Pakistan, India is big enough to sustain and prosper even having an eye on Pakistan, but it will be difficult for Pakistan to do so in long run. If Pakistani want development than they will have to change their mind set. Long live India & Pakistan. Jai Hind

    Reetesh, Hungary - 15 December, 2008

    Pakistan



    It is time for Pakistani people and its administration to change their outlook towards India. Cold War era has gone & its time for South Asian countries to rise up. Whatever mistake/action has taken place during the COLD WAR era has to be left behind. It is not hidden from world that Pakistan is engaged in proxy war with India (due to the alliance during COLD WAR & going blind eye towards Pakistan that period) on Kashmir issue, Punjab Indian side, now through Bangladesh & Nepal they are supporting various groups. However, the aim never got fulfilled and instead million of dollars have been spend which would have helped in building a strong nation instead it earned name of being sponsor of terror and covering druglords. Dawood would be getting same level of protection that a Pakistani head of the state or other diginitaries are geeting.

    What did Pakistan gain out of it ? 60 years of blood-shed and nothing has been gained. It has eroded the basic structure of Pakistan and now privately citizens are doubting the future. Instable Pakistan is not in national interest of India - is that which Pakistan banking & blackmailing world. Pakistan needs to understand that COLD WAR era has gone - may be today if USA is not supporting - China or Russia would but what if their is understand & alliance between Russia (to regain it old glory), China and India (aspiration of being global players) even Americans & Europeans will not come into play spoil because they have learnt that single power centre is not helping their cause - Afghanistan & Iraq are lessons they learnt.

    This is the time wherein Pakistani govt (choosen by people) to regain their certain elements (couple of days before it was declared that govt. have disolved political arm of ISI - Mumbai was attacked), throw people out like Dawood and work closely towards upbring of their state. It should not fear the growing Indian economy because they will very much reap benifits of. It is understood by Indains very much that is a hard time for Pakistan but at the same time opportunity for Pakistani to control & to do away with certain elements.

    Let me put up a confident face and say we will live like good neighbours though.

    Vince, Hungary - 15 December, 2008

    Pakistan negotiates with a gun to its own head



    Whether we accept it or not, extremists have more voice and influences in Pakistan than anyone else. It has grown up to the grass root level than anything else. These menaces has been encouraged by all dictators or democratically elected leaders in Pakistan for their personal benefits. Now it's beyond government's control.

    India blaming or asking Pakistan to take action against extremists doesn't make any sense. If at all Pakistani army or government (I like to mention both of them as two different entities) was capable of stopping terrorism then there won't be any terrorist attacks inside the Pakistan. Pakistan itself is very helpless. Pakistani army is very professional in paper, but not in reality. They couldn't protect just 57KMs of NATO supply routes between Pakistan and Afghanistan. If they can't protect just 57KMs, I doubt how they could protect a nation? If Pakistan can't maintain law and order in a particular area of own territory (NWFP), Pakistan is no longer qualified to keep NWFP as their own. Give them independence and world could deal with them separately.

    I would like to mention: Panjabi thugs are behind almost all calamities in Pakistan. They will deprive NWFP and Sindh Province by blocking river water and by securing all coal reserves of Sindh. Pakistan is in this situation because of Punjabis. All most all known terrorists are from Punjab, Pakistan. For them terrorism is a business. All of these uneducated thugs are driving four wheel drives and in reality it's their money making business in the name of religion. They can't get any other job, because they are not qualified for other than cleaning jobs. Now they are millionaires with all the luxuries and common man's survival in Pakistan is under threat.

    Pakistan have been threatening the whole world as mentioned by Irfan Hussain in The Dawn, “Years ago, a western diplomat wrote that Pakistan was the only country in the world that negotiates with a gun to its own head. Our argument, long familiar to aid donors, goes something like this: If you don't give us what we need, the government will collapse and this might result in anarchy, and a takeover by Islamic militants. Left unstated here is the global risk these elements would pose as they would have access to Pakistan's nuclear arsenal.”

    Undoubtedly, Pakistan created the mess and now asking the world to deal with it. If this is the case moving forward, definitely the world will handle the mess in Pakistan. But, it's not going to be the way Pakistan wants; hence it will be the way the world demands. That will be a catastrophe in Pakistan. Wake up, before it's too late.




    Jones, Canada - 16 December, 2008

    Intelligence sharing: selective or objective..?!

    Intelligence sharing: selective or objective..?!



    In the wake of Bombay tragedy the United States very proudly claimed that it warned the Indian government about a potential maritime attack against Mumbai at least a month before last week's (W.48) massacre according to the U.S. counterterrorism official who was talking to CNN. The U.S. intelligence indicated that a group might enter the country by water and launch an attack on Mumbai, said the very source, which refused to be identified due to the ongoing investigation into the attacks and the sensitivity of the information. Indian security forces have confirmed to CNN that not only did U.S. officials warn them of a water-borne attack in Mumbai -- they were told twice (once by Russians probably).



    Resultantly the area entered a higher state of alert for a week, including tightened security measures at hotels, but those efforts were eventually (or unfortunately) reduced, Indian officials said. Even the local fishermen (but not surprisingly the Indian intelligence agencies) in Mumbai said they witnessed a group of gunmen dock their boat Wednesday night, before heading toward the busy causeway.



    So this background raises some pertinent questions and clouds of suspicion which even make this tragedy look like a staged one (not for the innocent victims) as why this intelligence claim by the US was not shared with Pakistan..? Is Pakistan an ally or an antagonist in the so-called global war on terror..?

    Why the principle of sharing intelligence among the comity of nations, fighting against the scourge of extremism, is made selective instead of objective..?

    Did Americans, Israelis and Indians intentionally ignore to take the necessary steps to avert this tragedy or they wanted the perpetrators to go ahead with their agenda of massacre..? Wasn't this neo-cons last conspiracy (with the 9/11 profile) in connivance with the Indian and Israeli intelligence agencies to prove for the president-elect Barack Obama that Muslims in general and Muslim Pakistan in particular are not worthy of any favor over the issues like Kashmir, Palestine or what so ever..?



    Our leadership must put these questions and make it clear for the outside world (including Indians) that if you don't share the desired intelligence with us then blame yourself and don't come with the false and fabricated allegations or unrealistic demands (pressures) against our motherland (Pakistan) in the aftermath of such events because that not only demonstrates even underlines your biased and belligerent approach to the Islamic Republic of Pakistan..!



    Ahmed bin Babar

    multiways@hotmail.com



    Ahmed bin Babar, Pakistan - 16 December, 2008

    Peace and security for all humans

    Only peace and love must rule and that means that the humanity must act and move in brotherhood and taking care of fellow human of all the human race.This human caring and valuing human life must be the governing factor and point of creating terror free life all over the world.

    You cannot over look terror done by Indians through their cleverly manipulated network from hundred consullates in Afghanistan, finance suicidal bombings and then come railing on Paks with all mixed up unproven blames which are admixed with ambiguity.And yet some rabble roused un-clarity exists.

    Just look, that Indian financial support and happening of suicidal bombings in Pak cities, the human rights violations in Kashmir by Indian troops and such terror akin acts of India are not happening as the culprit is being sieved and sought out by global scrutiny.

    Obama must be praised for saying that he is for peace for all, and that statement applies to all trouble makers on planet earth including the rabble rouser Indian Jones for the peace and comfort of naive and innocent Paks in Pakistan and Indians of Mumbai and people of every place on planet earth.

    And the rabble rousers and cunning trouble makers like Jones must and must be checked from spreading hate instead of letting others doing construtive work of mitigating global terror.

    While the sane and noble efforts of majority and almost all humanity will concentrate on mitigating, solving and arresting the global chimera, odd rather singular like rabble rouser people like Jones is working on his own singular, unilateral and trouble making agenda of rotating hate against one segment of Pak society to the other in his ever Indian spy like spoiler of facts and figures.Jones hate mongering against Punjabis and Kashmiris and pathans has been very clearly evident in his cobra snake like ruffling through the peace lovers of humanity.To put this rabble rouser Jones to his arrested from restive itchyness of some evil raising and acting, I have some great American songs as such:

    First song is forty years old and was very popular in the world and goes as such:

    'I wish I had a big big camera,I would hang it up in space
    And take a family photograph, of all the human race
    Watch the birdy, watch the birdy, and every body say peace
    Yes every body say peace
    To make the whole world smile
    Yes every body say peace.

    The second song is also very old and was sung by America's all time best voice of Nat King Cole ia about human love(for all humans regardless of race and ethnicities). To put this ethnic blamer Jones to shame(if he has any), the love for all humans American song goes as such:

    'The greatest thing you'll ever learn
    Is just to love and be loved in return."

    This vemon carrying Jones, who has gone berserk against innocent Paks and Punjabis and Kashmiris and all other peace lovers and peace seekers is very apparent in his mad reflections of his spy-hood character and background in all his letters.

    A good sane human is for love of humanity as almost all humans of the world including the noble and peaceful Paks value human life unlike this hate centered Jones.

    Paks are as much peaceful and peace loving as other humans are and all peaceful and noble Paks deserve love and respect like all other noble humanity.

    Wrong and hate centric Jones can be singled out as deviant from other normal writers, who are more or less trying to do the mitigating work. They are not like Jones, who is hate picking Paks to satisfy and show his hate bred genes and DNA.

    We commiserate on the loss of life of innocents all over the world.You will shed tears of blood for all the victims and rail against perpetuators and financiers of troubles or all others ridden with guilt any where and every where.All sanes will commiserate on the loss of life in Bombay and they will also commiserate all other loss of life by other's in Pakistan or elsewhere.

    Justice and valuing of life in Kashmir and other suffering any where by evil financing is as much a must as caring and valuing human life in Bombay and Pak and other cities.

    A noble human will look at a hindu, muslim, sikh, christian, Buddist or a Jew or any one else of any religion or no religion with love from the bottom of his heart.A noble and sane human will have tears of blood over the loss of every valued life of all counties, ethnicities and clans instead of fire breathing on his hate pick of a specific nationality or ethnicity like this trouble maker Jones is doing in each of his hate laden letter.

    Shame on all such perpetuators.

    And this ANWAR loves all noble humans of India, Pakistan, America, Russia, China and all noble humanity.

    I can only summarize it all as such:

    "LOVE ALL YOUR GOOD FELLOW HUMANS, WHO CAN BE INDIAN, PAKISTANI, MUSLIM, HINDU, SIKH, JEW OR ANY BODY ELSE OF ANY COUNTRY OR ETHNICITIES.WE WILL ALL SURVIVE ONLY THROUGH LOVE AND AVOIDING INJUSTICES TO FELLOW HUMANS."




    Anwar Mahmood, Canada - 17 December, 2008

    Innocent ISI and Pak military and Paks

    According to the latest news and after interrogating the lone survivor in Bombay's unfortunate blasts, the FBI of America has found ISI of Pakistan not involved at all.These are the findings of America's and the world's best and prestigious intelligence on its fact finding interrogations.

    The very noble ISI and Pak istan military are only the guardian of peace, justice and protecting homeland and the world peace against very big odds around and under the most dangerous geo-stategy surroundings close by small and innocently well behaving Pak people, Pak government, and much loved Pak military and ISI.

    That rabble rouser Jones must be biting dust on these latest findings by FBI. Now he must be talking against an other noble entity FBI of America.

    Pakistan, a small country, is located on the crossroads of the toughest geo-strategy. Paks needs help in financial uplift to survive in the biggest struggle of the world's mightiest, who are embroiled in their own global interests through Pakistan, which is really and surely under-capacitated to meet the grandest geo-strategy related situations.

    America and China and all other peace loving natios should help Pakistan in developing its grand coal reserves so the country can have wide spread education and financial uplift.

    India and Pakistan can resolve couple of their thorny issues by very generous give and take attitudes, sign no war pact and promote love, justice and peace in all of south Asia without listening to the few trouble makers like Jones.

    Pakistan, with its very grand geo-strategy is lucky to have very strong, very capable and very much peace laden and peace minded ISI and military.

    Believe me you, Pakistan is a very lovable country and is the sweet, smooth and soft stress relief place after doing the responsibilities of the necessary yet work-holic culture of the west.

    WORK WHILE YOU WORK
    PLAY WHILE YOU PLAY
    THAT IS THE WAY
    TO BE HAPPY AND GAY

    SO WORK HARD IN AMERICA, CANADA, EUROPE AND JAPAN AND SUCH PLACES OF RESPONSIBLITIES AND THEN SPEND TIME IN THE SWEET AND VALVET SOFT AND SMOOTH STRESS RELIEVED LIFE IN PAKISTAN.

    JUST ENJOY THE TWO MODES OF LIFE-OF WORK AND PLAY AND YOU WILL LOVE IT IN PAKISTAN AS WELL AS IN US AND CANADA.

    AGAIN, CONGRATULATIONS TO ISI AND PAK MILITARY.AMERICA'S FBI SAYS THAT PAK MILITARY AND ISI ARE TWO VERY NOBLE ENTITIES.

    CONGRATULATIONS AND LOVE TO THE LOVED ISI AND PAK MILITARY. YOU WILL BE DEAR, LIKE PAK PEOPLE AND GOVERNMENT,FAR BEYOND FOR EVER.

    Anwar Mahmood, Canada - 17 December, 2008

    FBI Cleared ISI from Mumbai carnage


    I buy the news that FBI has cleared ISI from Mumbai carnage.

    Previously, FBI has said, General Kayani was aware and ISI was behind of Indian Embassy blast in Afghanistan which killed hundreds of innocent victims. What kind of action Pakistan has taken? Whoever is boasting about ISI's innocence on Mumbai attack shall respects FBI's previous note on Indian embassy attack as well. Does anyone have the guts?

    We cannot accept the reports are in own favor and disregard the reports against.

    FBI cleared ISI for the time being to save civilian government from further embarrassment. Diplomatic channel talks and press conferences are extremely different than the real talks and actions. Poorly educated, half assed thugs should gain wisdom to understand the reality. Undereducated thugs cannot understand what I am talking and they cannot understand what they are reading.

    Except feudal thugs, Punjabis (Pakistan) and Paktribune, almost all prestigious Medias in Pakistan have accepted the involvements of “elements” from Pakistan. “The Dawn” is the forerunner among news papers. It's a hard truth. Pakistan should wake up and stand against extremism.

    Pakistani army and ISI do not think like a common public. They are always cowards and behind of inhuman activities. In Kargil they disowned Pakistani soldiers. In Afghanistan they disowned ISI agents and Pakistani soldiers. These are hard facts.

    When tensions heightened between India and Pakistan on Mumbai carnage, they allowed mullahs to burn NATO supplies to send a message to US. They really think that others do not understand their activities. The issue is they think themselves that they are too smart. This is the worst behaviors I have seen with Punjabis (Pakistan). They think themselves they are the best. They boast themselves. World's best Gas Engineer (for belly dance and cat fight), World's best nuclear scientist, World's best army, Worlds best ISI, World's best Missile, World's best work force, World's best coal, World's best this and that and the lists goes on. If someone agrees that “I am not the best” then we can sit down with them and talk or teach or send them to school. If not, total outcome looks like “current Pakistan” and Anwar Mahmood.




    Jones, Canada - 18 December, 2008

    Please read it

    I have always seen pakistani media is supporting these terrorists and always spreading wrong news of harrasment of muslim people in India the future of pakistan lies only in hands of pakistani people but you media have kept them in dark so please wake up for god sake and try to save ur pakistan as terrorism nurtured by ur govt and army has grown up and harming pakistan more than india

    Mahendra, Hungary - 18 December, 2008

    Truth is coming out

    NEW DELHI: Indian Minority affairs minister A R Antulay demanding a probe into the shooting of Mumbai ATS A R Antulay reacts while interacting with media outside Parliament House in New Delhi.

    Chief Hemant Karkare in the 26/11 terror strikes which he linked to investigations into the alleged involvement of Hindu radicals in the Malegaon blast case. Stating that the circumstances of Karkare's shooting "may be inquired into".

    Antulay told the media outside Parliament's that "there must have been some reason why Karkare went to Cama hospital instead of Taj and Oberoi hotels."

    Antulay said "someone" could have told Karkare and other officers with him to go to Cama hospital, suggesting that the ATS chief fell victim to a set-up as he was probing cases which involved Hindu radicals in the Malegaon case.

    Reacting to the controversy, BJP condemned Antulay's statement and said the minister was as good as playing ISI's attorney and demanded his sacking.

    Antulay has been fulminating since Tuesday evening when the Cabinet cleared the bills for a National Investigation Agency and amendments to the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. He expressed apprehension that tougher anti-terror laws could well be misused, hinting that minorities were in the line of fire.

    On Wednesday afternoon, Antulay added to this script, telling TV cameras that apart from terrorism, the laws should also emcompass communal riots. "Those who riot are also terrorists," he claimed, seeking to provide what he felt was a sense of "equivalence" to the government's actions. But soon after, perhaps dissatisfied by his efforts, Antulay reappeared to claim he suspected foul play in the shooting of Karkare.




    wasi siddiqui, Pakistan - 18 December, 2008

    People in India are surprised as to why there are no protest march against Bombay tragedy. The people of Pakistan come on streets if a news paper publishes cartoons. The same people come on streets if a noble is written (Salaman Rushdi).
    Where are those people today. Should they not be on streets, condemning Bombay Tragedy. May be Kafir's (Hindu) life has no value!!!!! for Pakistanis. Vishnu Arya, USA

    Vishnu Arya, Pakistan - 18 December, 2008

    Control the State-terrorists to neutrlise the Non-state terrorists !!!

    Total Animals and Absolute cowards are George Bushes ,Tony Blairs , Narendra Modis , Lal Kishan Advanis and Lal Masjids tyrant, The reprehensible Parvez Musharaff and the God-forsaken hell-bound bunch of apologetic Muslims. Their crimes are far more heinous and their bravery conducted from the cool comforts of their comfortable abodes is 100% proxy and full of deciet and cowardice. Their victims are innocent and defenceless babies , women , old and sick and orphans. The acts of the 10 and the acts of 21 are and were the acts of reciprocation to deter and punish the heinous brutalities of these heinous brutes and cowards. Their exemplary bravery is in person and not proxy bravery. Allah O Akbar. They kill themselves to kill others to avenge and deter the killing of their fellow brothers and sisters. Allah O Akbar.
    The solution is plain and simple. CONTROL THE "STATE-TERRORISTS" AND AUTOMATICALLY THE "NON-STATE TERRORISTS" WILL EVAPORATE IN THIN AIR AND THE WHOLE WORLD THEREAFTER WILL LIVE IN PEACE AND HARMONY. PERIOD .

    Obaid, Pakistan - 19 December, 2008

    Since 1947 till now

    The separation of India and Pakistan, I would blame the mentality of people, that living so closed and never come to an understanding of Live and let live policies. Life is a blessing of God and now the India and Pakistan respect each others rights and keep the hate away from their mind. Think about it that we can do so much good in this region by solving our political issues firsts. We have not seen the change that happen in this world all over and not yet change our mentality to live in peace. Whoever and whatever forces are responsible for this mess will only do bad for themselves. After 911 India not only have taken the hate to the extreme level against the Muslims of India, more than any other country in the world. The colonizations of Muslims in certain part of Mumbai is also the reason where Muslims are treated openly with the inferior attitudes. The Muslims sides must not show some extra passions and do not do anything unusual that result in conflict with India. I know that pretty soon all this greedy people will get old leave this world with nothing. But the notion of hate is going to remain in this world for all their wrong doing. I think it is a time that a religion which has nothing to do with politics and blaming the people who are Muslims are something really not understandable. Every here and there those peoples who are responsible and make it habit to torture Muslims will know soon that they are harassing the people who are part of themselves because in "Quran" Allah has said that He create everybody with one soul, so how can we be different from each other. An Evil individual first of all is not a happy person and will leave this world with regret. The real torture of that person is that he is not closed to any religion and God. Taliban is name of that hate that could create a problem if generate in the heart of every Muslims that suffers the hate all over the world and their social welfare is being curtailed. The growth of Muslim's culture may be seen with the question mark but will promote the happiness in the heart of people. America is suffering why, due to the the war with the Almighty creator of this world. Passion is the virtue and Muslims not have to really worry about this and please do not do anything negative and wait and see these forces had targeted the religion of "Islam" and believe me Allah is Almighty

    Aslam Sheikh, Pakistan - 20 December, 2008

    Allah bless Peace to Paks

    None of the problems or the troubles faced by Paks are the makings of Pak people or government or ISI or Pak military.Unfortunately, the geo-strategy of Pakistan has put the country to big trial and trials akin to getting caught in the grinding wheels of the agendas of the mightiest, who are trying to manifest their all global interests from inside and outside of Pakistan.The exalted ones like Jones in forums haS left no stone un-turned in getting hell bent to be part of spy web to malign Pak military and ISI. And FBI of America has cleared Paks military and ISI to give a slap to the blaming faces, who are like ever Pak enemies.

    The world's grandest peace lovers and the peace entities like ISI and Pak military can pray to Allah to keep all wolves away as Paks have been sticking to their peace guns more so than any one else and like ever.Pakistan would have no problems if the country was located at some other geography.

    But, as they say that nothing can change the shapes of things to come.The mightiest ones have their so called sacred interests and agendas which they think cannot happen sans pak geography and geo-strategy.There are groupings and orientations being formed and reformed to use and interfere into Pak geography.All the ills of the whole world are being sought to be cured from and or through Pakistan's geo-strategy.

    Let us pray that all things stay and remain low key operations and the mightiest ones do not blow it all up into World war three.

    WE ARE LIVING IN A VERY DANGEROUS WORLD AND WE CAN PRAY FOR PEACE AND ALLAH'S HELP TO PACIFY AND CALM THINGS AROUND AND IN PAKISTAN DUE TO PAK'S MOST CRITICAL GEO-STRATEGY IN THE WORLD.

    NOBLE PAKS, ALONG WITH THEIR NOBLE MILITARY AND ISI ARE DOING GREAT SERVICE TO WORLD PEACE BY PEACE PRODDING WITH JUST ABOUT EVERY ONE.

    ONE THING TO NOTE HERE IS THAT SUICIDAL BOMBINGS HAVE STOPPED IN PAKISTAN AFTER BOMBAY MIS-HAP.MAY BE THE FINANCING BY OUR NEIGHBOUR TO THOSE NAIVE PEOPLE HAS STOPPED.

    BY ALL ACCOUNTS, PEACE AND SAFETY OF LIFE IS PRAYED FOR ALL HUMANITY AND THAT ALSO HOLDS GOOD FOR PAKISTAN AND INDIA AS WELL.

    LET US PRAY THAT ALL PAKISTAN AND INDIA AND EVERY NATION AND PEOPLE ENJOY SAFETY, PEACE AND PROTECTION LIKE IT EXISTS IN THE WORLD'S SAFEST COUNTRY CANADA, WHICH WAS DECLARED THE FINEST COUNTRY TO LIVE SIX YEARS IN A ROW BY THE UNITED NATIONS.

    LET US PRAY AND HOPE THAT ALL SOUTH ASIANS REMAIN SAFE AND PROTECTED, WHEN THERE WILL BE PRESSING AND INTERPOSING AND OPPOSING CIRCUMSTANCES IN AND AROUND THE WORLD'S MOST CRITICAL GEO-STRATEGY OF PAKISTAN.
    .

    ALL OTHER PEACE LOVINGS PAKS AND INDIANS AND OTHER HUMANS DESERVE TO LIVE IN PEACE AND HAPPINESS LIKE THE GRAND CANADIANS.

    Anwar Mahmood, Canada - 20 December, 2008

    Lack of Leadership

    unfortunately, Pakistani leadership has no vision for Pakistan or how to handle these terrorists. Not only should we appologise to India, but handover all and more of these jahadi elements to them for a tret, listed or not. This is a golden opportunity to rid overselves with these dangerous people who are hell bent to bring destructioin to this country.

    Syed H. Imam, United Kingdom - 21 December, 2008

    Act of denial ostrich like

    Animals who carried heinous crime against innocent unarmed humans have no religion. They were indoctrinated saying they are killing people of other faith, but alas they killed more people of their own faith. Surely, these animals cannot lie in peace even after they leave earth. Civilised society of Pakistan can continue to live in the state of self denial , hood winking the reality. This kind of self denial hasnt taken country too far. There are many other issues on which common Pakistani is fed with, other pet subject is Kashmir, condition of Indian Muslims etc. All these stems from basic building block of Pakistan , which is religion. Its time Pakistan's civil society kick this religious mindset in their private bedrooms and start accepting the world through eyes of plural, tolerant , secular mindset. The Animal farms which have been allowed to mushroom uncontrollably in Pakistan will one day bring colossal damage to unity of Pakistan. Society fed on extreme thought processes have never survived, history has shown that. Coward Animals will have to be eliminated from face of earth to bring peace and harmony.

    Sanjay, Hungary - 21 December, 2008

    Reasons

    Ever since we came in existence we have only been fighting may be because of some vested interest of few people in the name of islam or otherwise but we never think that we have people who are poor weak and no one to look after the money we give to people for quake victims gets utilised in procuring weopons etc etc we must concentrate that poor should be looked after neighbours have laid a trap and we have got caught in the same some want to dump there old weapons some ........... we must come up to save this part of the world else after 10 years we'll be no where we'll be 100 years behind then what

    jamall majid, Pakistan - 21 December, 2008

     What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

    Heading (Optional)
    Your Comments: *

    Your Name:*
    E-mail (Optional):
    City (Optional):
    Country (Optional):
     
     
    Field marked(*) are mandatory.
    Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

      Speak Out View All
    Military Courts
    Imran - Qadri long march
     
    Candid Corner
    Exclusive by
    Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
    Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
    Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
    Suggested Sites