Pakistan News Service

Wednesday Jun 19, 2019, Shawwal 15, 1440 Hijri
Pakistan News Home -> Speakouts -> Speakout

Ahmadinejad Suggestions

20 December, 2005

  Related News  
Obama repels new Iran sanctions push, for now
White House plays down Rouhani crowing on nuclear deal
  Related Articles  
America's first choice - Iran or Pakistan
By Asif Haroon Raja
Iran: Why war is not an option
By Sameer Jafri
  Related Speakout  
  More on this View All

Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad says the Holocaust is a "myth" and has suggested that the Jewish state of Israel be moved to Germany or Austria Europe or North America.

Addressing a gathering in the Iranian city of Zahedan last week, Mr. Ahmadinejad said the West has "fabricated a legend" which it holds "above God" of the systematic killing of 6.6 million Jews by Nazi Germany during World War II.

Ahmadinejad said that if Europeans insist the Holocaust occurred, then they are responsible and should pay the price.

"Today, they have created a myth in the name of Holocaust and consider it to be above God, religion and the prophets," Ahmadinejad said adding . "If you committed this big crime, then why should the oppressed Palestinian nation pay the price?"

"This is our proposal: If you committed the crime,then give a part of your own land in Europe, the United States, Canada or Alaska to them so that the Jews can establish their country," he said.

Ahmadinejad`s comments drew quick condemnations from Israel, the United States and Europe, which warned he is hurting Iran`s position in talks aimed at resolving suspicions about his regime`s nuclear program.

The White House said Ahmadinejad`s words "only underscore why it is so important that the international community continue to work together to keep Iran from developing nuclear weapons." Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev said the speech illustrated "the mind-set of the ruling clique in Tehran and indicate clearly the extremist policy goals of the regime." The German government summoned the Iranian charge d`affaires to express its displeasure.

Here are the questions
1) Is the holocaust a reality or spiced up with exaggeration?
2) What about Ahmedinejd’s proposal of moving Israel to Europe or North America?
3) Is this justified that Palestinians pay the price of “holocaust” committed by Germany ?
4) What could be the impact of Ahmedinejad’s statement on Iran, which is already under criticism for its nuclear programme?

Reader Comments:

Moving Israel to West

A good opinion to the west as a whole given by the Iranian President.
First thing is to see that why the west is so eager to increase the quarrel with Iran.
Then the second thing is that how brave is the united west to raise a conflict against any muslim country and how will they be ready to solve the problem in any peaceful way. They do not possess any sympathy to Israel.
The answer is only that "The west is in high esteem of power".

Shirin, Pakistan - 21 December, 2005

Ahmedinejad has a Valid Point

Like President, Ahmedinejad, I also believe that since the Europeans committed the crimes against the jews, therefore, why should the Muslims of Palestine pay for that crime ? Israel should have been created in Europe. Since the Americans feel so strongly about the right of Israel to exist, they should give up some of the land they had stolen from the native Indians for Israel and relocate Israel inside the US. That would be a just solution to this problem, but I never expect that to happen as long as America remains a super power. Americans and the Europeans love to talk of Israel,s right to exist, at the expense of the Muslims in Palestine.

Tarek Masud, Bahrain - 21 December, 2005


Anyone who expresses negative
about Holocaust is doomed by
the West.On the other hand if
that person was to condemn
Prophet Mohammad(PBUH)and say
it in open,that person would
win the admiration of zion.To
freely express yourself,You
must belong to the zion club.

KhalidRahim, Canada - 22 December, 2005

The Suggestion.

In which part of Alaska or Canada would the Iranian head
of state like Israel to be moved? Next he would ask the
Sunnis in Iraq to be move to
Falkland or the Antarctic.

Khalid Rahim, Canada - 22 December, 2005

Ahmadinejad Suggestions

I agree with the Iranian president.Debate is mandatory.Above Allah,
Nabi, and the religion the leaders such as bush blair paul martin with wmd and rebellian democracy have passed bill of parliament. They have established gay lesbian marriage,invasion .None existant Saud family in 1912 have taken into custody Mecca and Medina mosques with prophet muhammad pbuh buried .The Problem began in 1912 in Balkan with declared war on turkey( 1914) in serbia bosnia bulgario albania east europe with Lawrence of Arabia while Balfour declared a home for 22000 palestinian jews in 1917 as bani Israel .By using Allah Quran Nabi model a Jewish home has been established and then they abandoned Allah via gay-lesbian marriage bill.This development brought ww1 ww11 nazi war,six day war,Iraq war, Alqaeda Afghan war,Osama Bin ladin ,Iran war 9/11 ,serbia ,bosnia chechniya war .Now instead of 6 million palestinian living there ,Balfour's 22000 Jews (now 5-6 million jews) are occupying 80% of land.. 11 out of fourteen 9/11 alqaeda terrorists came from Custodian country Saudi Arabia.With this excuse they invaded iraq and they are not quitting.Canada is so big that 99 israel will fit in Canada's provinces or 50 france.Blair Bush Martin as above God bills ,sanction , massacres invasion consider muslim as threat to security to oil supply army and resident of Israel.Iranian President said even if above God religion nabi factor can be justified but holocaust is a myth with projected 5-6 million population factor.
The creators of Israel should install them elsewhere rather than attempt being made to evict Iran President
ayotollahs(evil of axis ) muslims of the region (instead).President of Iran recommended that Almighty God be reinstalled via debate.

Zakaria_Belal, Canada - 22 December, 2005

Iranian President's defination of "above God".

Creation was recreated with forecast that united gangup DuCanada Networking
group(Du canada Dujjal)if go beyond hudood( yehud ) Saddom Gumrah Gay
lesbian marriage practice will end up in quarrel wars-water pollution for further
recreation.Beyond hudood DuCanada Dujjal which started via Lawrence
of Arabia-Saudi -Turkey -Jewish war(1912-2005)."Above God " gay lesbian alcoholic
invading leaders bush blair martin lawrence of arabia kings have closed down
biblical christianity and converted muslims into just two
mosques religion with the Holy prophet in Medina under
house arrest(custody) with Israel issuing warning to iran amid global muslim bashing

mohammed_belal, Canada - 23 December, 2005

Ahmadinejad Suggestions

We in America believe the holocaust occurred because we have been told they found the camps with physical evidence that coincide with what survivors told in their stories. Allah himself does not want 2 states, he said this in the Bible, so the Jews are not living according to what God said he wants. There is one God, one religion, until everyone realizes this there will be no peace because his laws are not being followed, particularly to treat everyone as brothers. Palestinians are not less than Jews. Until the Jews recognize this they will continue to be "those feeble people" as God described them in the Bible. We don't want Sharon here, so please moving Israel to North America is not a good idea. The Palestinians were chosen by God to be martyrs, as is the descendants of the tribe of Benjamin which have settled in Afghanistan and today are called insurgent fighters. I think Iran needs to maintain a nuclear program for self protection. Look at a world map, country by country you can see each country being taken over by US forces. Iran will not be left as a sovereign state, after Cheney gets rid of the regime in Lebanon and Syria, he will take Iran, and then the End Times will come when he tries to get rid of all the Palestinians.

gina, United Kingdom - 23 December, 2005

I know Holocaust Survivors

I know a number of Holocaust Survivors (mostly child Survivors). There are one or two who attend my Synagogue. These people bear their concentration camp serial number tattood on their arms.

Please don't deny the Holocaust. Religious people saying there was no Holocaust are like the Medieval Catholic Church torturing Galileo because he claimed that the sun had spots.

Ya`akov N. Miles, Canada - 24 December, 2005

Psyche of Expansionism

The question is not about the existence of Israel, rather it's about the psyche of supporting expansionism or coloniasm. Through out the history we have witnessed that rulers had have beleived in expanding their kingdom one way or the other. Whether it's justified or not, is a different ideological wishful thought, the reality is that once you gain the maximum power or might in this world, what should you do if not expand?

Christians believe to conquer the world with missionaries, Muslims have done it through missionaries and might, and in the recent history Jews have strategised their expansionist policy through empowering the intellect of their community and they have been quite successful.

I beleive, while rehtorics can make an impact over the media, but the real war is now to strategise the power of intellect. Muslims are being too emotional by using slogans, such as, "Death to America", "Death to Israel", instead of using' "Engage America in a dialogue" "Engage Israel in a dialogue"

But in the end, I still have not been able to understand the Psyche of Expansionism? One thing for sure, it's more than Greed!

Agha, Pakistan - 25 December, 2005

Iran can kill Israel with kindness

Itanian Mullahs have puffed themselves to becone "Ayatullas" and "Ruhullas". Iran is no better than Iraq. It is even worse in that it is an odd man out even in the Muslim Ummah.
Ahmadinejad has wiped out all the good work that his predicessor Khatmi had done. The new president has made himself a laughing stock.
Jews were prophesied in a true and "sahie" Hadith to assemble in the holy land. Somebody should read it out to Ahmadinejad. There is a complete consensus on this "saying" of the holy Prophet (p.b.u.h). Israel is a curse on itself. Ahmadine- jad is at best only at making enemies and provoking them to come and attack Iran. Its people worship the cult of sublime Hazrat Imam Hussain. They have no voice in the affairs of the state.
Palestine should be deemed lost to the Palestinians and at little loss to them. The country in the possession of Israeli Zionists is under a cloud of divine retribution. Zionist faction of Jews had bid good bye to the Jewish God
at the founding ceremony of Israel. "Where was God when we were being exterminated in the Holocaust." the Zionists asked? Islam has no part in the intermitent divine punishments to the Jews. In fact Allah is also "Merciful and a dispenser of grace" to the peacenik Israelis.
Iran needs an internal shake-up and to rid itself from the cult worship.
We shouldn't get surprised if Israel strikes a blow or two to Iran at any time in near future,

Sher mohammad.

Sher Mohammad, Pakistan - 25 December, 2005

It was wrong for Mr Ahmadinejad to say those bad things about the Holocaust and Israel.

Mr Ahmadinejad must say sorry for saying those bad things about the Holocaust and Israel.

By saying those bad things, he has only made Iran come under even more scrutiny and puts his presidency into question.

Razur Rahman, United Arab Emirates - 25 December, 2005

Muslim Ummah is much ignorant about Israel

On reading general comments of various people, it appears that the true picture of Israel is not clear to them. The Iranian president, Ahmadinejad appears not only completely ignorant of Jewish history but he also presents a bizarre figure in the diolomatic circles.
Jewish uncontrollable nostalgia and its deep love for holy land can be guaged from the fact that no Jew would ever ask another Jew to abandon the Holy Land. Their moans and bewailings for their lost country innthe first exile in Babylon were answere in not only their return to the country but God also empowered them over the enemy and restored their former grandeur and supremacy. Please, refer to 'sura' "Bani Israel" early verses. No people were ever made by God, before or after, as exalted as the Israelis. Yes, they also are a queer folks, radical, stiff-necked, and rebellious. It may be that they represent the combined vices of all previously destroyed communities for their "kufr" and denial of divine "Truth" as an example to other nations, but there are also pious and saints among them to justifytheir survival, "unto the Day of Resurrection."
One had expected from Iran an interaction with Israelis to woo and wean some of them towards Islam by telling them the apocalyptic appearance of Imam Mehdi on one side and the "Dajjal" (Antichrist) on the other side. How naivety on the part of Ahmadinejad to ignore the coming of Imam Mehdi and Jesus Christ. If Israel were to be shifted to Europe, or Canada, etc., does he mean that the promised Imam were to travel all the way from Mecca, and Jesus Christ from Damascus in hot pursuit of the israelis?
It is time that a true picture of the "essential" creation of Israel should be made clear and its reality accepted by the Muslim Ummah. Palestinians have no place to live with the Israelis. One only needs to browse on the "Zionis websites" to know the deep hatred of Jews of each other and the worst vices practised in Tel Avive, where prostitution is not considered any vice at all. Indeed, Jews on the one side have a most exalted place over mankind and on the other they degrade themselves at the lowest level of voices.
As for as Ahmadinejad is concerned, the sooner Iranians dump him the better for them and for the image of islam!

Sher Mohammad.

Sher Mohammad, Pakistan - 26 December, 2005

to Khalid Rahim, Canada

Typical Muslim. I see you do not want Israel in your beautiful new country of Canada. Guess what, I hope a Jew moves next to you so everyday that Jew can take his dog onto your lawn to do his business! I hope in your hell you are surrounded by Jews. Then again maybe having you around would be their hell. You Muslim Dog.

Joe, United Kingdom - 26 December, 2005


Tarek, as typical of you, you speak crazy talk. Israel is hated for many of the same reasons the west or Microsoft is hated.....they have power. Israel won a war with that land years ago...and your land was at one time occupied by others. The reason they are still around is that they are powerful and smart. The reason Iran won`t mess with Israel has nothing to do with the US, it`s because Israel will destroy Iran.

It`s absurd to move Israel away from Jerusalem. Would you consider moving away from Mecca? Put some time into thought before you post next time.

anonymous, Georgia - 27 December, 2005

Jews always tell a lie.

Holocaust is very big fraud of 20th century.

Dawood najafi, Trinidad And Tobago - 27 December, 2005

europeans are responsible for holocaust

course is the europeans who massaccred millions of jews , and on the other hand the israelis are doing the same thing via other methods to palestinians. And if iran is getting questioned over nuclear issues , then so should every other country on planet earth. every country has the right to defend itself. Fianly I would hope and wish this world can get rid of these devastating weapons.We dont need them shouldn make them .

asif, United Arab Emirates - 28 December, 2005

Hi ! G I Joe.

What do you know about True Torah Society? I have nothing
against Jews and hope they come to cordial terms with their adversaries.Only if the
Zionists allow them to seek those terms and let the folks
in Levant live in peace.Let's
observe the forth coming elections in West Bank and later in Israel to find what
the ordinary people want.The
Holocaust of the Jews is in the past and now they live and prosper, by inflicting same wounds on Palestinians.
I would rather have a humane jew friend than a venegeful
muslim.Finally why are YOU so keen to pick quarrel with
the Muslims.

Khalid Rahim, Canada - 29 December, 2005

The Iranian President is an emotionalized, sorrowful, parochial minded disaster. He seems to be relishing the world media attention right from the day he took office last summer (a little before that actually). He's probably a manic who wants to take on the West and Israel without realizing the power and the might of those countries. He's providing every excuse to George Bush and Company to attack his downtrodden country and thereby screw up its poor citizens. Leaders like him are a wrath of God. He should be overthrown or made to leave ASAP otherwise Iran may soon find itself down on its knees, thanks to the insanity of Ahmadinejad.

Ahson Saeed Hasan, United Kingdom - 30 December, 2005

myth ? ?

Mr Iran's Presitend Just put the "concentration camp" words into search engine and take a look. You will see what has happend here in Europe some 60 years ago. If you do not want to do it, so I am inviting you to visit my country or simply visit me and I will take you to places to see whole sad history of Rusian, Israeli, Polish and other nations during the WW2. I am not Jew, even from my background but I think that everyone on this planet should know what has happend, when, why and who did it. It is importent to remmeber it to not do it never again by any nation to any nation.

tomek, Pitcairn - 31 December, 2005

Holocaust a "myth"?

How can the Holocaust be a myth? I know people personally who went through it.

Ya`akov N. Miles, Canada - 01 January, 2006

 What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)
Your Comments: *

Your Name:*
E-mail (Optional):
City (Optional):
Country (Optional):
Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

  Speak Out View All
Military Courts
Imran - Qadri long march
Candid Corner
Exclusive by
Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
Suggested Sites