Pakistan News Service

Thursday May 24, 2018, Ramadan 9, 1439 Hijri
Logo Logo
Pakistan News Home -> Top -> News Details

SC dissolves Shoaib Suddle commission

08 December, 2012

  Related News  
AG Qadir questions judges' conduct in Dr Arsalan case
Riaz files petition against 'unlawful' Suddle commission
  More on this View All

ISLAMABAD: After the submission of Dr Shoaib Suddle commission's interim report about alleged Rs 342 million business deal between Dr Arsalan Iftikhar and real-estate magnate Malik Riaz Hussain, the Supreme Court has dissolved the commission, saying that this is an issue between two individuals and they can take it up at any forum.

A two-member bench of the apex court, headed by Justice Jawwad S Khawaja, on Friday dissolved the Suddle commission while allowing findings of the report to be made public. During the hearing on Friday, Arsalan's counsel, Sardar Ishaq, requested the bench to dispose of the matter, arguing that his client's reputation was being damaged on TV channels. Likewise, Zahid Bukhari, counsel for Malik Riaz, also pleaded to stop the commission's proceedings so that whichever party wanted to take whatever legal recourse, they may approach the avenues concerned.

Special Assistant to Prime Minister on Political Affairs Fawad Chaudhry while talking to our sources said that the purpose of the commission was to "clean the dirty laundry of Arsalan Iftikhar". He also questioned why the court did not decide the legality of the commission on Malik Riaz's review petition. Fawad also said that Malik Riaz could approach Islamabad police to register a case against the chief justice's son

The CJP had himself on June 5 took notice of the alleged business deal between his son and Malik Riaz. On June 14 the court ordered the attorney general of Pakistan (AGP) to take strict action against the main characters of the case – Dr Arsalan Iftikhar, Malik Riaz and his son-in-law Salman Ahmed. In its order the court had noted, "Nonetheless attempts by individuals to obstruct the course of justice are indeed a matter of serious and grave concern and imperil the reputation of the justice system at large. This is why such exchange of bribes with the attempt, even a failed one, to influence the course of justice, has been declared illegal and punishable under various laws. If proven guilty by a court of competent jurisdiction, the parties involved are liable to be punished."

In compliance with the June 14 order, the AGP had referred the matter to NAB for a probe, but Dr Arsalan raised questions over the impartiality of NAB's Joint Investigation Team and filed a review petition against it, which was accepted by the SC. On August 30, the court formed a one-man judicial commission headed by former police official Dr Shoiab Suddle and the incumbent federal tax ombudsman to probe the alleged business deal which was aimed at influencing the judicial process.

The one-man commission was given full judicial power under the Supreme Court Rules 1980 and authorised to collect evidences either at local level or internationally, and directed to submit its findings within 30 days. According to the commission's preliminary report, the CJP's son has admitted before the Dr Shoaib Suddle Commission that he had availed two of the three foreign visits alleged by Malik Riaz. Arsalan Iftikhar has also confessed that he had received 'favours' from Malik Riaz, his friend or his son-in-law, but it does not answer why he had accepted these and the businessman's claim that he had 'favoured' Arsalan in order to get court cases settled in his favour.

According to the report, it is widely believed that the motive behind Malik Riaz's 'plan' was to defame the chief justice and bring the higher court into disrepute. On the other hand, the report is silent about how Arsalan Iftikhar became a millionaire in no time and entered into telecom contracts worth Rs 900 million. The Shoaib Suddle Commission has implicated Dr Arsalan Iftikhar and Malik Riaz in massive tax evasion of Rs 51.3 million and 119.4 billion, respectively,and recommended imposition of a penalty for concealment of assets in wealth statements filed with income tax returns.

The commission observed that there will be zero tolerance for any misconduct on Arsalan's part, as being a son of the chief justice, it is absolutely critical that the highest standards of integrity set by the chief justice are not allowed to be compromised under any circumstances.


Reader Comments:

If all are crooks like that

You don't dis-own or throw out your family crooks. It is sad if such things run in the close kin of CJP, who was seen carrying legal whip to correct the bad guys.

Sad is enough, if his own son escapes even after proven bad. Then would you throw all bad fish in the pond to do whatever suits them -- right or wrong.

PM Gilani is gone due to proven bad stuff. Would the nation bring him back and say adios to his substitute PM Ashraf or jail Arslan if proven guilty.

I guess the judiciary and the military may be the beyond reach for any rule of law. The judiciary runs the laws which may be exempt from action when they or their kins do it wrong. The military has not just the whip but the guns that can be fatal if you press too hard on them for their wrong acts. But, military is there to save us from our sworn foe or adversary and military needs the most leniency as it is well understood. Actually I, like all other patriots must love my armed forces because they are the only armed insurance for us against our sworn foe who is openly talking to slaughter us all Paks. Even cricket fan like Khaled Mahmood was sent dead back home after the Indian police snatched his Pak passport and labelled him with wrong blame. Our blind cricketer was given acid to drink. I would therefore be the last to hurt Pak military from inside and would never ever visit India even if given millions of dollars bribe. I draw my pleasure from the fact that Pak military has enough nukes to keep India away. I draw pleasure from the fact that Indian rivers are drying with melting of glaciers and the bastardly Saudi and American help to India for energy supplies is failing to stop Indian economic growth rate from fast falling in last couple years. I love China who has grown dozen tiimes more wealthy and powerful compared to India and China is our best friend.


A.M.Rogers, - 09 December, 2012

 What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)
Your Comments: *

Your Name:*
E-mail (Optional):
City (Optional):
Country (Optional):
Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

  Speak Out View All
Military Courts
Imran - Qadri long march
Candid Corner
Exclusive by
Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
Suggested Sites