Pakistan News Service

Sunday Feb 17, 2019, Jumada-al-thani 11, 1440 Hijri

Stranded in troubled neighbourhood

05 October, 2006

By Riaz Missen

  Related News  
US seeks to ease Pak-Afghan tensions
Kabul I Love You brings Afghan woes to the big screen
  Related Articles  
The Afghan imbroglio
By Imran Malik
Indo-US unethical pressures on Pakistan
By Asif Haroon Raja
  More on this View All

India’s history owes much to the Ghaznavis and Ghauris of Afghanistan. Musghals were the latest to reach Delhi via Kabul. The empire they would construct would last more than a millennium.


Anglo-Saxons drew the western borders when they happened to rule India. They had taken up the country’s South in a fit of absent-mindedness. The rest was conquered deliberately with a promise to push the Central Asian nations back to their natural confines.

The Anglo-Saxons have never abandoned Pakistan while the country strived to keep the western borders of the subcontinent intact for the sake of its own survival. During the Cold War era, Americans were in the lead. Europeans have also entered the scene after the fall of Soviet Union.

Pakistani and NATO forces are manning Durand Line now. Does India owe anything to Pakistan? Is Afghanistan thankful to its eastern neighbour for the labour it has borne to ensure its integrity? Pakistan is really obsessed with these questions; it does not suit to the interest of neighbours to impress on Pakistan that it is doing only a thankless job.

Why Pakistan is blamed by India and Afghanistan for fanning militancy in the neighbourhood? Why they thrust on Pakistan the responsibility to defend the porous borders on its own? Why they behave so irresponsibly when their neighbour strives to find stable ground to set its foot on? Can Pakistan abandon legacies so easily as the leadership of Kabul and Delhi tend to suggest? Why they want only Pakistan to taste the fruit it had not sowed the seeds of?

What really Afghanistan wants by restoring stipends of about 2200 notables of the tribal belt falling in Pakistan? Why India keeps on informing the world that its western neighbour is responsible for acts of terrorism on its soil?

Pakistan is less likely to be used as a scapegoat now onward. Afghanistan and India have to end the accusation game and come up with reasonable solutions as to how to manage the porous borders they happen to share with Pakistan.

Pakistan is gifted with moderate size country in terms of natural and human resources. The hostile neighbourhood is the main reason for its being under the shadow of unitary system of government. Militancy seeped into body politic to ensure existence in the turbulent strategic environment. 

The prospects of Pakistan’s returning to normalcy depend too much on the attitude of the neighbours towards it. So far no country around it has turned receptive to its strategic woes. The rest have dumped their worries along the banks of the Indus River in the past; they are not ready to abandon this course even now.

The Pakistani decision-makers are very much alive to the need of restructuring the body politic as per the demands of the global age. They have managed to keep its economy floating, diplomacy moving and politics functional while its borders keep on burning for last seven years. Would Afghanistan and India agree on a mechanism to manage the porous borders along Pakistan?

Are Manmohan and Karzai the sorts of souls who will forget the turbulent past to secure the future of one-fifth of humanity? Had India seen beyond the tip of its nose, its history would have been different. Had Afghans had stable ways ever, their country would not have been bombed by the daisy-cutters.

The uneasy neighbourhood has proved a great constraint on strategic thinking in Pakistan.  Meagre resources but mammoth responsibilities have put it on the path it is aspiring to abandon in global age. The more its borders will become stable, the more its pluralist, essentially tolerant, face will become visible.

While the neighbours behave irresponsibly, Pakistan must not necessarily follow the suit. Peace is the strategy that answers effectively the questions posed by country’s strategic environment. Raising standards of civility in diplomatic discourse with neighbours is the first step to this direction, rooting out militancy from its soil the other.

This strategy has already delivered. Parliament is functional for last four years, economy has been liberalised, and media is vigilant while judiciary is on a pro-active course to define freedom of people and groups in the new age.

Propagation of the message of peace and love delivered by the Muslim saints in its deserts and planes and showcasing the statues of Buddha in the footsteps of Himalayas is a policy that makes operational part of Pakistan’s strategy to ensure peace at home. It will necessarily transform the challenge posed by porous border into an unparallel opportunity as well — the people of Indus Valley know very well the art of winning the hearts.


Reader Comments:


Hey Riaz, you've written everything right but got confused in one important respect. Instead of typing Pakistan you should have typed India and Afghanistan and vice versa.

nsrao, Pakistan - 05 October, 2006

Troubled Neighborhood

It is not India and Afganistan accusing Pakistant of terrorism around the globe, but the whole world is talking about ISI and Jehadis being trained and armed and then sent around the globe. Mr. Karzai put it rightly that if you train a snake, it is going to bite you some day. In fact it is happening in Pakistan right now. Therefore, it is better to wake up to the reality and see who is responsible for the troubled neighborhood. I understand your patriotism, but the truth is truth.

Ramesh K. Sharma, United Kingdom - 06 October, 2006


When a democratic leader like Manmohan Singh or a well educatedKarzai or free foreign media blame Pakistan and its so called leaders ( who most of the time happen to be from military background) of instigating terror or stirring tactics to save themselves.., there must be some truth in it . How long the educated people like you, Mr Riaz, will keep on defending your crazy rulers!

Max, New Zealand - 07 October, 2006

Something to worry about

I just can't understand why Pakistanis aren't able to see the obvious. Not a single discordant voice from Pakistan? It is really something to worry to see people are made like the 'dead walking and chating' --- remember, 'Judgement Day', Terminator III' or 'Mummy'?

The problem is that Pakistanis are never taught to live a hard life. Pakistan has subsisted on foreign aid. Arresting terrorists for money, from the CIA, is not what a sovereign country's government does. Why not to differentiate between honour and dishonour?

I am not against you waging a war against India per-se. But why did you do Kargil when your politicians were striving for peace and giving all the right gestures. Why is your country not manly enough to declare a war and fight? Are you proud to be the best back stabbers in the world?

Vengat, Hungary - 10 October, 2006


Only india is accusing Pakistan and Afghanistan following it. Your "truths" are all lies. Dont talk to Pakistan about snakes, your India created and supported the LTTE that blew away your PM.

Aamir Ali, Pakistan - 10 October, 2006


I dont accept that military rulers are automatically crazy. Bush and Blair are not from military background, but both are warmongers.

Blaming is one thing and proving the blame is another. Something printed in the media is never proof. You can print anything and give the flimsiest of reasoning, it will still fill the article.

Aamir Ali, Pakistan - 10 October, 2006

Good article

The simplistic fools in India and abroad believe that all the troubles originate from Pakistan and the solutions are in Pakistan as well. This fact points to the incompetence and ignorance of Indians, Afghans and others. Given the multiple insurgencies in India and Western failures in Afghanistan and Iraq, Pakistan is in a relatively safer position.

Abbas, Pakistan - 10 October, 2006

Vomit from a dumbass Indian

Kashmir is not a part of India hence you Indians cannot be complaining about Kargil. Additionally india has been one of the largest beneficiaries of foreign aid, you may have forgotten that in your fervour of indian nationalism.

Aamir ali, Pakistan - 21 October, 2006

 What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)
Your Comments: *

Your Name:*
E-mail (Optional):
City (Optional):
Country (Optional):
Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

  Speak Out View All
Military Courts
Imran - Qadri long march
Candid Corner
Exclusive by
Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
Suggested Sites