Pakistan News Service

Saturday Jul 20, 2019, Zul-qaadah 17, 1440 Hijri

'Siachen Accord'

24 November, 2006

By Prof. Khalid Mahmud

  Related News  
Pakistan demands India pull out Siachen troops
No breakthrough in Indo-Pak talks on Siachen
  Related Articles  
The Siachen key
By Momin Iftikhar
Pak Army - Let Martyred Soldiers Defend Siachen
By Zaheerul Hassan
  More on this View All

What makes foreign minister Kasuri so optimistic about a Siachen accord in the offing is anybody’s guess. The day Pakistani delegation left for New Delhi to resume the stalled composite dialogue Kasuri said an agreement on Siachen will be reached within days. Earlier on he had, contrary to what the signals from New Delhi suggested given, the good news that a ‘breakthrough on Siachen’ had been achieved.

Ironically, Parnab Mukherjee who held the defense portfolio before he became India’s foreign minister in a major cabinet reshuffle by prime minister Manmohan Singh, had then brushed aside the speculation that the Indians were now prepared to pull out troops from the line of actual control in a package deal for demilitarisation of a ‘zone of peace’. And since then reports have appeared in the press that India’s military establishment was opposed to altering the status quo in Siachen if it required troops withdrawal from any territory held b y India since its occupation of the glacier, called the world’s ‘highest battle field’, in 1984.

Kasuri’s optimism may have been caused by a ‘communication gap’ or he may have been tricked into believing what he has been saying by New Delhi’s traditional gimmickry. Double-dealing is an established trait of Indian diplomacy. They are quite capable of saying one thing in closed door negotiations and another in their public pronouncements. And they have been taking the joke too far by renouncing explicit understanding reach in talks or even backing out of an accord which awaited signatures by the two sides before being made public.

The several rounds of talks on Siachen held in the 1990’s had met the same fate. When Islamabad thought they were on the verge of making a deal, the Indian negotiators had second thoughts and took a U-turn to call off talks. Critics said it appeared that someone high up in the establishment had told them to stay put, but whatever was the reason for the Indians to get cold feet at the eleventh hour, it was a classic instance of the zero sum game the Indians have been playing to resolve issues of mutual discord, Siachen being on top of the list.

One wonders why is Kasuri so pushed about claiming a breakthrough on Siachen, while the Indians have kept their cool. Perhaps he wishes to take credit for salvaging the composite dialogue from a tarnished image, by putting across the message that it has not been as futile an exercise as critics suggest.

We have not ended up in a blind alley, the foreign minister would like to reassure his countrymen, or been forced to console ourselves with a ‘one-way traffic’ of concessions to the Indians. It has therefore been necessary for him to raise hopes of a positive response from New Delhi if not on Kashmir, at least on Siachen, which given the input of substantive talks and narrowing down of divergent positions in the past is perhaps easiest to handle of all the disputes on the agenda of Pakistan-India talks.

Nevertheless, Khurshid Mahmood Kasuri is seen as a man in indecent haste to prove that he has done a great job as foreign minister and his diplomatic endeavour has been well-rewarded. Political pundits suggest he may be well advised to be a little more prudent in projecting outcome of Pakistan-India negotiations if he wants to save himself the embarrassment of making a false move, or being caught on the wrong foot. Let him take his cue from the poker-faced occupants of the South block in New Delhi who do not reveal their true self until the zero hour.

Small wonder foreign secretary Riaz Mohammad Khan has returned home empty handed from his visit to New Delhi where Siachen was also on the agenda for talks in the much-awaited composite dialogue. Briefing newsmen after the two-day talks the foreign secretary said ‘we have not reached an agreement on Siachen, as both sides still have reservations. The failure to secure a breakthrough on Siachen which Kasuri had the audacity to insist was just round the corner, has since been underplayed in Islamabad, as other matters, such as anti-terrorism and nuclear safety steps are being highlighted to suggest that the resumption of composite dialogue was after all not a non-event. Consolation prize for the Pakistani foreign minister, he is scheduled to go on a visit to India next month.


Reader Comments:

Whats there to resolve ?

Why Should Siachen be resolved? so that at a later date, you again do a kargil at Siachen and then gift it to China? what you can't win in battlefield can't be won through negotiation. Its as simple as that.

Vivek, Hungary - 24 November, 2006

Forget Siachen

Why u guys r so optimistic ? India is never gonna give anything to u. If there is a crack in a glass (or mirror), it can never be repaired. U guys have lost the trust. Wars with India and kargil r perfect examples of back stabbing. Generations will give such examples when there will be a talk about the word 'back stabbing'. Discussions r a tactic and everybody knows about it. Nothing gonna happen. Ultimately what will happen, we will be on the economic & prosperity peeks and u people will be still looking at ur feet. So buddies, say 'good morning' and wake up. Think about economy, poverty and democracy, and not about Siachens or J&Ks. I am sure (from the past history) that u guys will never say 'good morning', but still best wishes.

Patriot, Canada - 25 November, 2006

Use your brains!

I seriously cant understand why any of the pakistani inteligista cant see India's game plan. They know that there is no miltary solution to kashmir, only a economic one. Hence there insitance on commerce. They are just soft stone walling the negotiation with all main powers and neibhours while there economy zooms ahead at 8 or 9% per year. They know in 10 years time, if there economy is 4th or 5th larget in the world, they will have immence clout in the world forum to settle all issues to there liking. We should forget about contigious issues and try to bring our economy back in track, else we will left further and further away from india in all dimensions. Stone walling is a game 2 can play, only if our so establisment use there brains.

Omar Mailk, United Arab Emirates - 25 November, 2006

Best option

For the sake of peace between india and pakistan,india should not with draw from its positions in Siachen.Once with drawn PAKISTAN WILL REOCCUPY SIACHEN AND START TROUBLING INDIA WITH THE HELP OF CHINA. So for the sake of peace STATUS QUO IS THE BEST OPTION.

Babu, United Arab Emirates - 26 November, 2006

Still think you can be trusted?

Like your foreign minister,you people just continue to hope against hope that India will again trust you and withdraw from the hard won territories so that Pakistan army can don Pathani salwars and kameez and walk into the vacated peaks as Mujahideens.Even thinking of such a possibility is preposterous.After the shamelessness executed in Kargil, double-talk by your "CEO" (denying any involvement in Kargil,not accepting your dead and then acknowledging all in his book) how can you expect India or any Indian to trust you?

Saurabh Gaur, Seychelles - 04 May, 2007

 What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)
Your Comments: *

Your Name:*
E-mail (Optional):
City (Optional):
Country (Optional):
Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

  Speak Out View All
Military Courts
Imran - Qadri long march
Candid Corner
Exclusive by
Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
Suggested Sites