Pakistan News Service

Monday Nov 20, 2017, Rabi-al-awwal 1, 1439 Hijri
Logo Logo
LATEST :

Setting India on Fire!!!

03 November, 2008

By Farzana Shah


  Related News  
'Hindu terrorism' in India is a fact: Salman Khurshid
Ajmal Kasab hanged till death in India
  Related Articles  
Hindu terrorism exposed
By Asif Haroon Raja
Is India Behind Mumbai and Lok Sabha Attacks?
By Zaheerul Hassan
  More on this View All

Mahatma Gandhi on Dalits

"It is a matter of deep humiliation to confess that we are a house divided against itself, that we Hindus and Mussulmans are flying at one another. It is a matter of still deeper humiliation that we Hindus regard several million of our own kith and kin as too degraded even for our touch."

M.K. Gandhi`s address to the US through Columbia Broadcasting System in 1930s:

Such discrimination, as noted by Gandhi himself, forced many Dalits to convert to Islam, Budhism and Christianity, in the hope of gaining some social standing in the society that refuses to consider them human otherwise. But the VHP led Hindu right took this to be an unforgivable sin. To abandon their religion and that too for Islam outraged the hardliners to the core. The VHP saw this as a serious threat to its notion of Hinduism.

India, the world`s largest secular democracy is everything but that. This rhetoric sounds good but only for so long.  It becomes nauseating when this hypocrisy takes such toll that humans are openly butchered in the streets while the government prides itself to be a representative of those very people.

Prologue

Indian history of the past sixty years has been marred by religious, political and communal violence. An interesting trend to note is that only certain religious issues become prominent in politics; causing agitation and leading to communal riots. This essay attempts to ascertain the sociological, psychological, economic, and political explanations for incidents of communal violence, in Gujarat, Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Bengal, Maharashtra, Orrissa and Delhi in India.

The first major riots that occurred in India between Hindus and Muslims after the bloodshed of partition in 1947, can be traced back to as long as 1961, in Jabalpur a central Indian state of Madhya Pradesh. (sic) They were followed by riots in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh with periodic violence erupting elsewhere. Thousands of Sikhs were murdered in Delhi in 1984. The assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi at the hands of two Sikh bodyguards triggered further violence; a response from Sikhs at the killing of innocent worshippers at the holy shrine when the Indian Army stormed into the temple with full force under her orders. But the roots of present day violence can be best traced to the 1980`s.

Hindu mob is beating a helpless Sikh during violence against Sikhs in Delhi in1980.

Sikhs burnt alive in the streets of Delhi. (1980)

Gujarat riots of 2002 were another horror story where thousands of Muslims were burnt alive, raped and slaughtered by Hindu fascists in the first genocide of 21st century. The recent anti-Christian violence in India is being viewed by the world with concern as it is a sign of how quickly such violence can spiral out of control.

The last thing the world wants is another incident similar to the Gujarat riots of 2002 or the destruction of Babri Masjid of 1992, which gave way to months of fierce unrest.

Following the demolition, some 2000 people were killed in communal riots in Ayodhya, Bombay and beyond. Hindu hardline parties, including the Vishwa Hindu Prashad (VHP) and Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) - used Ayodhya as a rallying call to Hindus throughout India. They said the 16th century mosque at the site was located on the birthplace of the Hindu Lord Rama and that a temple had to be built there. The temple till date has not come up but the memories of the destruction of the mosque still haunt the minorities in India.

Some blame the Muslim movement for an independent Pakistan as the source of division in India on the basis of religion. But religious intolerance has not remained confined to Muslims only. Other minorities including Christians and lower caste Hindus, otherwise known as dalits, have also borne the brunt of the fascist Hindu ideology that fuels this violence. The problem is much bigger than what is taken to be in explaining these disturbing tendencies. In all the mentioned incidents what remains consistent is the fact that the aggressors are always fundamentalist Hindus, who seek justification of their horrendous sins in divine rulings. Thus this mindset can be best made sense of with an understanding of Hinduism itself.

“Inequality is the soul of Hinduism,” wrote Ambedkar. He characterized the oppressive caste system as the tyranny of Hinduism. After spending a lifetime in a crusade against the oppressive Hinduism, Ambedkar finally renounced Hinduism, and converted to Buddhism and exhorted his followers to do the same. It is an irony that BJP and other Sangh Parivar outfits are trying to appropriate such a historic personality as Dr. BR Ambedkar.

Some claim that India was a country that preached non-violence ever since the Vedic period. This sounds ironic especially when today`s India has become a conundrum of violence with BJP-led Saffron Brigade trying to create a Hindu Rashtra.

This has resulted in terrible and outrageous violence against the minorities living in India, which in actuality define the secular credentials of India.

The new wave of attacks against Christians was triggered by the killing of a Hindu leader, Swami Laxanananda Saraswati, along with five other people at Tumudibandh, Kandhamal District, in Orissa on 23 August 2008.

The rebellious Maoist Naxalite groups prominent in this region have claimed responsibility for the murder of Swami and his followers. In addition, the state police authorities have stated that the killing was carried out by the Maoists. However, leaders of certain fundamentalist Hindu organizations like the Bajrang Dal and Durga Vahini blamed Christians for these killings. Despite the condemnation expressed by Christian groups and churches at the killing of the Swami and his associates and their demand for the culprits to be caught and punished, in retaliation, the extremist Hindu organizations have engaged in a series of attacks against Christians throughout the Sate of Orissa.

The minority Christians in Orissa have been experiencing various forms of atrocities in recent weeks including looting, destruction of churches and church-run institutions, brutal attacks against priests, nuns, church workers and other members of the Christian community, most of whom are Dalits and Adivasis (tribals).

Reports from various sources confirmed that at least fifty thousand Christians in Orissa have been displaced; hundreds of Christians have fled their homes and taken refuge in forests; many others are living in as many as eighteen relief camps, which offer them only so much relief in the wake of the mayhem that has wrecked their lives. 

The plight of the victims and survivors of this communal carnage, the fear and trauma they are experiencing, the poor and unhygienic facilities in the government-run relief camps, the inefficiency of government machinery in tackling the violence, continue to be a serious concern.

The upsurge of religious extremism in Orissa in recent weeks has left many Christians in Orissa virtually defenseless.

(House belonging to Christian family burnt to ashes. Thousands of houses of Christians were burnt by Fanatic Hindus during recent violence in Orissa and other states of India).

Insight into the communal violence in India

Though Hindutva ideologues often try and confuse matters by claiming that India is already a Hindu Rashtra, which translated in English means a "Hindu nation", they know that their model of Indian society, if it is to come about, requires the prior establishment of a Hindu state under Sangh control, which in coordination with the RSS, alone can dramatically re-shape the Indian society/polity demanded by a proper Hindu Rashtra. But there are only two routes to achieving such radicals strong state power — through an electorate to secure an absolute or near-absolute majority for the BJP in Parliament; or bypassing altogether the constitutional-electoral route and carrying out an authoritarian coup either of a military-police kind, or a civilian unconstitutional coup of the Emergency-type. Through this a dominant but minority party comes to power in a coalition through elections but then overthrows all democratic-electoral restraints and establishes its authoritarian state. Fascism in Germany and Italy combined t

he electoral and unconstitutional processes and attained central control in this manner.

Gujrat is being used as a rallying point by BJP, RSS, Bajrang Dal, Durga Vahini, Balidani Dasta of Bajrang Dal, Shiv Sena and Vishav Hindu Parishad. Taking it to be the starting point, they wish to take their malicious agenda forward to Orissa and beyond.

Organized violence against Christians in India

This new wave of organised violence against Christians, which started in Orissa, has now spread to other States such as Madhya Pradesh, Karnataka and Kerala.

Attacks launched by Hindu extremist groups against the Christians are considered as an well thought-out plot and just one link in a long chain of events that have continued to strain communal harmony and inter-religious relations in the country. Although the attacks against Christians are interpreted as religious violence, in most circumstances the under current is based on socio-economic factors. Christians in the country have been repeatedly accused of encouraging conversion to Christianity. Various Churches have been unequivocal in their official documents and statements and have insisted that conversion to Christianity by force or fraudulent means is strictly prohibited. 

(Cross at stakes: Many Churches destroyed in Orissa recently )

Churches being vandalized in Delhi 

3. What the constitution of India says?

Contrary to what the Indian constitution states in terms of protecting minority rights, Hindu militant groups are trying to replicate the example of Bajrang Dal. The Bajrang Dal was set up in 1984 as the youth arm of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, Mr Prakash Sharma was made its Kanpur unit convener. At that time, it was “active only in a few districts of Uttar Pradesh. Today it has some 13 lakh activists spread across most of the States and the aim is to cover every district of the country. The Bajrang Dal leader denied that his organisation was involved in the violence against Christians in Kandhamal district of Orissa or in Mangalore and elsewhere in Karnataka, although the Karnataka unit chief Mahendra Kumar, had issued a statement accepting its role. Mr. Sharma listed the tasks before the Dal as “seva” (service of the people) and “suraksha” (protection). Its volunteers were given tough physical training to help them protect themselves and the people. He insisted that they were not trained in firearms, and were trained only in “aiming with air guns for which we run regular camps.”

Mr Sharma very openly and nonchalantly admitted that the minorities can only live in a Hindu Rashtra if they stop preaching their religion. “We do not say do not go to mosques or churches. But conversion must be stopped. We have re-converted to Hinduism through the Ghar Vapasi (home-coming) programme about 10,000-15,000 people since I became Bajrang Dal convener in 2002.” 

Here is another chilling reality that somehow is escaping the Government of India. The violence and threats against the Christians/minorities of India is an assault on the Constitution of India. The Indian Constitution declares India to be a “sovereign socialist secular democratic republic” which secures to all citizens “justice; liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; and equality of status and opportunity”. Under articles 14, 15 and 16 of the Indian Constitution, discrimination based on religion is prohibited. Article 25 guarantees the right to freely practice and propagate religion. In addition to these constitutional guarantees at the domestic level, India is also party to several international treaties that stipulate human rights obligations. Article 18 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights establishes the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion. Article 26 bar discrimination on the grounds of religion while Article 27 stipulates that in “those states in which ethnic, religious or linguistic minorities exist, persons belonging to such minorities shall not be denied the right, in community with the other members of their group, to enjoy their own culture, to profess and practice their own religion...”.

India now has seven states, which have legislation banning religious conversions. The seven Indian states with anti-conversion legislation (known as the Freedom of Religion Acts), include Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Orissa, Arunachal Pradesh, Rajasthan, Gujarat and Himachal Pradesh. Hindu extremists commonly use anti-conversion legislation to falsely accuse Christians of converting people through force or allurement; thus justifying subsequent attacks on Christians. They also deflect prosecution away from themselves by pressing charges of “forcible conversion” without any evidence.

The response of the church in India

Atrocities committed against Christians are horrendous and their unspeakable state is no less than a nightmare. In August 2008, a crowd of up to 4,000 Hindu militants attacked the Brethren in Christ Girls Hostel at Nuagoan, one of nine such facilities funded through the Scholarship Program for International Children’s Education (SPICE). The mob set the hostel and church ablaze, destroyed its water tank, and demolished the campus. Ten policemen who were on guard at the hostel fled when they saw the approaching crowd. Staff, girls, and local believers, some of whom were beaten, managed to flee. The Cuttack-based offices of the Brethren in Christ Church in India were also a target, and several pastors and church planters lost all their belongings when their homes were looted and burned. People, including pastors, who had to take refuge in forests, lost everything. They are without food and clothes and at risk of snake bites and malaria.

The Churches and Christian leaders in India have been making persistent efforts for appealing to people to strive for peace and reconciliation. The call given by the Untied Christian Forum comprised of the National Council of Churches in India, the Catholic Bishops Conference of India and the Evangelical Fellowship of India to observe a Day of Prayer and Fasting for Peace and Reconciliation was very well received by Christians all over the country. People at large have appreciated the efforts by various churches to promote and restore trust and goodwill among people of all religions and communities. The Church leaders in India appealed to all members of Christian community in the country to work for the welfare of all sections of people in society in spite of such horrific experiences of violence and death of some members of the community.

The World Council of Churches is deeply disturbed by these developments of religious violence in Orissa and has expressed its concern in a letter by the General Secretary addressed to the Prime Minister of India. A pastoral letter from WCC General Secretary expressing sympathy and solidarity to suffering Christians in Orissa was sent to WCC member churches in India and the National Council of Churches in India.

India, Secular?

Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh strongly defended India`s secular credentials when the European Union conveyed its “serious concerns” over attacks on Christians in India. “We are a secular state. We are a multi-religious, multi-cultural nation,” Manmohan Singh said emphatically. “The Constitution guarantees all citizens of India the right to profess and propagate a religion of their choice,” he said. Manmohan Singh admitted there have been “sporadic attacks” on Christian shrines but underlined he had already condemned these incidents as “acts of national shame.”An `act of national shame,` indeed it was. But such gruesome violations of human rights demand a more stern response than this. The Indian Prime Minister was covering it up cosmetically since he had to do it. But the ground realities are absolutely different. As the growing religious extremism and increasing violence against religious minorities in India is putting the secular credibility of India at risk

The reality check India should go in for

Secularism is a term employed most rashly by the Indian National Congress. The Chief Minister of South Indian state, Tamil Nadu made his mind clear regarding this and launched a scathing attack on the Prime Minister.

Questioning the secular credentials of India, Karunanidhi alleged that the Congress was neither a true secular party nor a force that was interested in the country`s integration. Referring to the killings of Sikhs in the north in the wake of assassination of former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, he wondered whether the Congress could be called a secular party. Secularism was not a term to which the Congress alone could claim ownership; he said asking "have the people given patta (title deed) to the Congress to use the term?"

Karuna Nidhi had carefully chosen his target when attacking the Congress for he was aware that India has not been able to free itself of communalism even after more than sixty years of independence, however much it tries to deny it.

If anything, it has been getting worse year after year. There has not been a single year in post-independence period, which has been free of communal violence though number of incidents may vary.

Indian talks of pluralism, secularism and a great tradition, are made to seem nothing more than a mockery by the Hinduvta dream of carving out a ‘Hindu Rashtra`.

Now there are few incidents that would stun the readers:

In the year 2002 the first reported riot took place in Kozhikode (Calicut), Kerala on 3rd January. In the clashes between two communities (Hindus and Muslims) five persons were killed. The clashes occurred on the question of eve teasing. The whole region came in the grip of violence. More than twenty persons were injured including five women. Properties worth lakhs of rupees were destroyed. The police had to be heavily deployed to bring the situation under control. Kerala in India is generally thought to be free of communal violence, experiencing only occasional frenzy and bout of communal violence. But this time a vicious terror campaign overtook it, aimed at its Christian community.

Gujarat was next to come under the stretch of communal carnage. Nowhere in history can there be found an example of the violence of this kind in India except at the time of partition. The communal carnage in Gujarat shook the entire world. It was difficult to believe such intense communal frenzy could be incited by the BJP for its political gains. More than 2000 people were killed most cruelly in this carnage according to very reliable sources even though Government records show dead to number no more than 1000. What is worse the Chief Mister Narendra Modi justified such frenzy and described it as reaction to action in Godhra. And all this happened with full complicity of the police and bureaucracy. The honest officers who did not allow carnage in their areas were instantly transferred by the Modi Government.

Some ministers who led the mobs have been named in FIRs. Many mosques and mausoleums were demolished and ground was leveled. Some accounts maintain about 700 such religious structures were brought down or severely damaged. Ahmedabad, Baroda, Mehsana and Panchmahal districts were the worst affected districts covering entire north and central Gujarat. Properties worth more than 10,000 crores were looted or burnt, though these figures are disputed. The business loss due to closures and migration of labor is several times this figure. Hundreds of Muslim families were totally uprooted. The carnage continued for more than five months

On 17th March communal incidents took place in Loharu in Bhivani district of Haryana. Loharu was once under a Muslim ruler and was known as Nawwaab of Loharu, which explains the considerable number of Muslims residing in that town. A mob of three hundred incited by the rumour of cow slaughter attacked two mosques and at least 15 shops and houses belonging to the minority community. The police had to fire in the air when the mob could not be controlled by cane charge. When the people belonging to the majority community heard that a cow has been taken for slaughter in one of the mosques, the mosque, and close by shops were set on fire

According to a UNI report quoting the police sources said that a mob of 300 Shiv Sainiks set fire to another mosque near the railway station also including many shops in Purana Bazar. And in this area all 15-20 shops and houses belonging to minority were burnt down. The palace of Nawwab of Loharu was also surrounded by a mob but additional reinforcements were requisitioned from other places which were thus saved from being damaged.

Next incidents of communal violence took place in three places in Rajasthan in which three persons were killed on 25th March on the occasion of Muharram. The immediate provocation was the holding of poornahuti yagnas (a Hindu religious ritual) and Kirtans (devotional songs) for Rama at various temples on the route of Tazia processions. Curfew had to be clamped in the town of Gangapur, 80 kms from Sawai Madhopur, in central Rajasthan where 3 people were killed and 15 injured in police firing.

According to the police violence broke out when activists of the VHP, BJP and Bajrang Dal collected at an ancient Hanumanji Mandir for a Yagna and Kirtan. The police asked them not to gather but they defied police orders and began to shout provocative slogans when the Tazia procession came closer to the temple. The police was compelled to open fire when tear-gassing and cane charge had no effect.

The Gangapur city has 25% Muslim population and earlier was considered to be the stronghold of SIMI (Students Islamic Movement of India) in Rajasthan. It has always been prone to minor communal irritations although this is the first time that violence has erupted on such a large scale. In different parts of Southern Rajasthan where the Sangh Parivar has strong presence communal tension was simmering. But the situation was kept under control. 

Christians’ massacre starts again:

The recent wave of the communal violence in Orissa`s Kandhamal district was an `unprecedented` attack on the Christian community in India, according to a rights group in its fact-finding report. `We are saddened to acknowledge that the violence in Orissa, which left at least four killed and 730 houses and 95 churches burnt, will go into the history books as an unprecedented attack on Christians in India,` said Joseph D`Souza, president of the All India Christian Council (AICC). `The tragedy is deepened by the fact that the violence was avoidable if the authorities had enforced the rule of law”.

Bajrang Dal activists have been involved in bomb blasts often blaming it on Muslims, so as to prove their stance on Muslims being responsible for the terror activities in India. Today spokesmen of the Congress led UPA Government in India are asking for a ban on Bajrang Dal. The faster it is done the better it would be for India as a country as there is every reason to believe that it may just implode from within as political parties like BJP have undertaken a mad, mad cannonball run.

RSS/VHP/Bajrang Dal and its activities

The RSS was founded in 1925 by Keshav Baliram Hegdewar is the ideological fountainhead of the modern Hindutva movement. Organized around the concept of Shakas, a local cell formation where young men would gather for physical and ideological training, under the tutelage of a brother or dada, the RSS ideology as espousing the national cause was articulated over the next decade or more. Madhav Sadashiv Golwalkar, who was appointed the head of RSS shortly before his death by Hegdewar, clarified the idea of the nation in his treatise:

"We, or Our Nationhood Defined": We believe that our notions today about the Nation are erroneous... It is but proper therefore, at this stage, to understand what the Western Scholars state as the Universal Nation idea and correct ourselves.

Based on a racial idea of Nation Golwalkar in praise of Hitler says: To keep up the purity of the Race and its culture, Germany shocked the world by her purging the country of the Semitic Races - the Jews... Germany has also shown how well nigh impossible it is for Races and cultures, having differences going to the root, to be assimilated into one united whole, a good lesson for us in Hindustan to learn and profit by”.

These Hindu extremist organizations are also imparting military training to Hindu youth for taking on non-Hindus. The formal training is now underway to ensure the spread of a militant ideology.  The Shiv Sena chief has condoned the arms training of the Bajrang Dal.  He also mentioned that the Indian army is ill-prepared for war and that his political party, the Shiv Sena also will be arming their cadre.

At the Sarojini Nagar Camp of Lucknow this is what was released to media: “The number of people being trained in the Sarojini Nagar camp at present is 100.  But according to the convener of UP branch of Bajrang Dal, Avadh Bihari Mishra, the objective of this camp is to prepare a group of two thousand trained and active young men who could train a million youth in martial arts and handling of arms in camps at various places.  In addition to this, the objective is also to create such atmosphere and mentality which was seen in the country at the time of demolition of Babri Masjid.”

Women branch of RSS/Bajrang Dal armed militants

 Among the Sangh Parivar’s affiliate organizations actively participating in giving training in martial arts are the RSS’s women’s branch (Rashtriya Sevika Samiti), the Bajrang Dal and the Bajrang Dal’s women’s branch (Durga Vahini).  Though training camps and trainings are not new for these organizations (they have been imparting training in “lathi” wielding and riot mongering for a long time), they have now started arming their volunteers in a military pattern.

Though the current training exercises are being carried out with air-guns, the Bajrang Dal state chief Ved Prakash Sachan said he plans to give volunteers a feel of real guns.  “This is the induction stage.  Later we will train our boys with proper guns and rifles,” he admitted over the telephone, while claiming, “This is part of our drill to ensure protection of Hindus.” Sachan is personally supervising the camp, which was not the first of its kind in the state. According to him, similar camps have been held in Varanasi, Mathura and Meerut.

(Females activists of Durga Vahini, the women wing of Bajrang Dal are being imparted weapons and sword training at its camps for taking part in future activities against minorities.)

Chronology of terrorist activities by Bajrang Dal, RSS

* Aug 25, 2008 : Two die in Kanpur when a bomb explodes. It transpires these were Bajrang Dal activists who were making explosives. 

* Aug-Sept 2008: Spate of attacks on Christians in Orissa and Karnataka. Karnataka unit head Mahendra Kumar arrested. Home ministry says Bajrang Dal is behind the attacks

* April 2006: Two Bajrang Dal activists die in Nanded while making bombs. Of them included a suspect of the 2003 Parbhani mosque blasts

* Jan 1999 : Dal mob led by its local leader, Dara Singh, burnt alive a Christian priest Graham Stains and his two little sons in Orissa 

And the list continues as the saffron assault brigade takes charge of turning India into a Hindu Rashtra. The Bajrang Dal is said to have been at the forefront of murderous gangs that killed Muslims and burnt their homes in Gujarat in 2002. On several occasions, Dal activists have acted as moral police, catching unmarried couples on Valentine`s Day and forcing them to apply sindoor or tie rakhi against their wishes. The record of Bajrang Dal`s lawlessness is endless. And now the Dal, the 24-year-old sword-arm of the Hindutva brigade, is in the news again — as almost always, for wrong reasons. A number of political leaders have been demanding its ban.

In the middle of September, anti-church violence erupted in Mangalore where prayer halls of the evangelist New Life order were attacked. Soon violence enveloped other denominations, and then churches in the new economy city of Bangalore were vandalized. A month earlier similar anti-Christian attacks rocked Orissa and trouble is still simmering there.

In the middle of the violence that broke out in Mangalore was the figure of Mahendra Kumar, Bajrang Dal "convener" for the state, who claimed responsibility for some of the attacks, said they were a "spontaneous Hindu upsurge". While the Dal said it was inflamed by New Life`s "conversion activities", prayer halls were not the only targets. The Adoration monastery, where nuns live a cloistered life, dedicated to prayer, was not spared either, its windows broken and crucifix vandalized. Saffron groups and Christian organizations have clashed over conversions and re-conversions as they jostle for influence from remote tribal homelands of Rajasthan`s Banswara to the north-east. 

 Human Rights report of violence against Christains/Minorities in India by saffron parties 

“Christians are the new scapegoat in India`s political battles. Without immediate and decisive action by the government, communal tensions will continue to be exploited for political and economic ends”, says Smita Narula

Researcher, Asia Division of Human Rights Watch

The problem is that poverty is eating into India and the people are finding Christianity a lucrative option with many NGO’s working overnight for conversions. Conversions are not forced upon yet they number highly due to the desperate living conditions in India which have been worsened by the food shortages. An escape from death in return of a faith that has only served them humiliation is considered a fair deal by many downtrodden Indians. It is basically in Northeast of India that includes states like interiors of Assam, Meghalaya, Nagaland, Manipur and Tripura where conversions have been high. Down South it is Orrissa, Kerala, Karnataka where Christain NGO’s have gone overboard with the conversions. And that is irking the saffron parties since they are seeing this to their own dream of ‘Hindu Rashtra’ and that is where the problem begins.

The Indian government has failed to prevent increasing violence against Christians and is exploiting communal tensions for political ends, Human Rights Watch charged in a report released this month. The 37-page report, Politics by Other Means: Attacks Against Christians in India, details of violence against Christians in the months ahead of the country`s national parliamentary elections in September and October 1999, and in the months following electoral victory by the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (Indian People`s Party, known as the BJP) in the state of Gujarat.

Attacks against Christians throughout the country have increased significantly since the BJP began its rule in mid of March 1998. They include the killings of priests, the raping of nuns, and the physical destruction of Christian institutions, schools, churches, colleges, and cemeteries. Thousands of Christians have also been forced to convert to Hinduism. 

The report concludes that as with attacks against Muslims in 1992 and 1993, attacks against Christians are part of a concerted campaign of right-wing Hindu organizations, collectively called the Sangh Parivar, to promote and exploit communal clashes to increase their political power-base. The movement is supported at the local level by militant groups who operate with impunity.  

Conclusion:

When Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati, a charismatic Hindu priest fond of railing against Christian missionaries, was shot dead in the eastern state of Orissa in August, police blamed “Naxalite” Maoists. But hardliner Hindu groups decided Christians were responsible. In an ensuing rampage, dozens of churches were burned, tens of thousands of Christians fled their homes, and at least 20 people died. By this week the violence had touched four more states. In Karnataka in the south, 20 churches have been desecrated in a few days.

India’s Hindu majority and its tiny Christian minority mostly rub along peacefully. But since the early 1990s, the rise of ideological Hindutva (“Hinduness”) and of the Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), now the main opposition, has seen intermittent outbreaks of sometimes vicious agitation against Christian missionaries. They are accused of forcibly converting poor Hindus. Gauri Prasad Rath, general secretary of the Vishnu Hindu Parishad, or World Hindu Council, in Orissa, says that the thuggery was caused by, “the fraudulent conversions Christians are doing. They burned their own churches.”

However the claims of VHP are mere accusations as all the funds Christian organizations get from abroad are thoroughly monitored by government in India, as opposed to the huge funds Hindu extremist organizations like VHP, RSS and Bajrand Dal spending on different terrorist activities which have never been audited.

It is true that missionaries are busy in much of India, especially the tribal belt that runs through Orissa. Here, traditionally nature-worshipping forest dwellers, among India’s poorest people, have found institutional Christianity, with its free schools and health care, especially attractive. Indeed many church leaders believe that the proportion of Indian Christians is a couple of percentage points higher than the census reckoning of 2.3%. In six of the 12 states ruled by the BJP, either on its own or in coalition, laws designed to discourage Hindus from switching faiths by banning forced conversions have been introduced. Convictions, however, are rare. Muhammed Shafi Qureshi, chairman of the government-appointed National Commission for Minorities, says on inquiring as to how many people had been convicted under the state’s 1967 law; the answer was none.

Tensions have been exacerbated by a row over “reservations”, the affirmative-action benefits, such as privileged access to government jobs and education, afforded to low-caste Hindus.

Most Hindu converts to Christianity come from the lower castes but lose these benefits when they switch faiths. Their calls for inclusion in the system have infuriated many Hindus.

With general elections due by next May, such issues have proved effective rallying cries for Hindu groups aligned with the BJP. Mr Qureshi points out that Karnataka, scene of some of the worst violence, this year voted in its first BJP government. The party is also part of the ruling coalition in Orissa. “This madness”, he says, “is political.”

Every conflict can be explained in more than one way, but historians know that one way of sifting out bad explanations is to look for plausibility.

Here, we’re being asked to believe that the thousands of extremely poor people who make up the populations of these relief camps are self-arsonists running a compensation scam. This is not just a bad explanation; it’s an explanation made in bad faith. What we’re seeing in Orissa is the attempt to replicate Gujarat’s ‘success’ and Golwalkar’s object on a smaller scale. Thus, Christians are driven out of their homes to live in limbo as destitute, vagrant wards of the State in camps, or else allowed to return to their villages as neo-Hindus purged of an alien possession. This is, or should be, unacceptable. The use of murder, rape and arson against civilian communities to achieve a political object (in this case ethnic cleansing) is a form of terror, and this republic’s government needs to treat it as such.

As the violence spreads to many districts of India against Christians after Orissa episode, other minorities including Muslism are also being targetted. Just today (October 12, 2008, Sunday) six Muslims of a family including 3 children were burnt to death at Watoli village Andhra Pardesh district when their house was set on fire. The village is 13 km far from the communal violence-hit Bhainsa town. Three bodies were charred beyond recognition, the rest were burnt partially, police said.

Keeping in view the numerous incidents of violence and massacre of minorities at the hands of extremist Hindus in India, the credentials of being a Secular country are highly questionable.

The slogan of being biggest democracy and a secular country seems only a rhetoric and catchy phrase to bluff the world.

Though recently US and UN have expressed concern over massacre of Christians by Hindu fanatics in India but there is a need for more strong a measure to be taken by the international community in this regard.

The world should take notice of the brutalities being meted to minorities including Christians and Muslims and low cast Dalits by Hindu extremists in India; the matter should be taken for debate in the United Nations by the world so that these oppressed people of India can get some justice.

----------

(Inputs from different news reports, Human Rights organizations’ reports)

 

Reader Comments:

Aap khud apni adaoon pe .....

it is investigated that India involves in Pakisan's terrorism ,India supports those groups with musad Which are not tolerate Pakistan's strong stretigic position, Isnshallah Future will ours .

Abdul Rab Nishter, Pakistan - 01 December, 2008

Lack of study

I think respected madam, Miss farzana just have collected the material from internet and trying to hide Isamic terror acts all over world wide. I agree that, those responsible for Malegaon blast are equally guilty. But what about those hundreds of blasts, comparison to just one or two. The reporters and journalist from Pakistan should find out the reasons for why their country is heading towards extremism. They should focus on the issues like education, technology and other fields. There is no use by publishing such articles. These just urges the muslim youth to participate in terror acts like recent "attack on Mumbai". You are misguiding your own public. We can Take care of problems with our muslim brothers in India. Miss Farzana should go through the list which I mailed her regarding the terrorist organisations in her own country. Thank you very. I wish my article will e published in Pak tribune. I will be thankful.

Amol, Hungary - 01 December, 2008

Shameful for India

Absolutly agree with Adams. India has blood of millions innocent chritians and other minorities on its hands. Need to cut off.Where as in neighbouring Pakistan where there is relegious threat from Islamist, there is no violance against christian and minorities. Its a great surprise why world not looking at this big difference. My view point is India is the real threat to the world

Peter, Antigua And Barbuda - 03 December, 2008

Bad Seed

There is something deeply disturbing and twisted in all these religions & cultures. I cant put my finger on it. No wonder western culture and conventions prevail in one form or another all over the world.

zarak, United Kingdom - 04 December, 2008

The problem with Pakistan is that right from the days of its nascent nationhood to date, it is more bothered about India than about itself (as the author's argument well illustrates here). India's democracy is far from perfect but it is indeed a democracy unmarred of any military coups. I have closely followed the Pakistani media and well over half their editorials are always lamenting over India. It wold do a lot of good to Pakistan to look at their own inadequacies (which are in galore) rather than try to peek into their neigbor's backyard. Today India has reached the Moon while Pakistan is still stuck fomenting hate against India. Look at the Indian newspapers. There are hardly anything on Pakistan's internal conflicts (of course this has changed lately after the Mumbai attacks). I will encourage the writer to write something about her own country and be more constructive. This neigbor bashing will not do anything for Pakistan (which is close to being declared a terrorist state and a failed state).

John, United Kingdom - 11 December, 2008

LOOK WHO IS TALKING.....

dear palz,
I accept that the raging violence against the minorities
is shame to Indian democracy...
But I'm surprised to see Pakistani's and Bangladeshi's commenting on it. First of all, look whatz happening in your country... I wonder u people have nerve to talk about violence against sikhs (Remember how sikhs men were brutally massacred and women were gang raped by pakistani's during partition)...

, Hungary - 15 December, 2008

Proof

I would like to publish these articles in the major newpapers in Canada and USA but I need proofs to convince the auditors that the information provided is real. Can You please provide me references?
Thanks

Tanveer, Canada - 19 December, 2008

all this shows indian federation is about to break

hasnain, Pakistan - 21 December, 2008

India and it's friends

Ms Farzana Shah very thoughtful article, as they say a person is known by it's friends same goes for the countries as well...let's have a look at India's best friends..Israel..which is hated by all Arab countries but because of it's military strength and American back up they have to put up with it even recent terrorist attacks on Phalestine by Israel and US open support for Israel should open Muslim world leaders eyes who still think that Israel, US and india can be their friends..another friend of india is USA that is basically running all indian economey right now...just to to use it as a weapon or footstep to defeat China..USA war in Iraq is the biggest example of terrorist act committed by a country...USA mislead whole world to beleive tha iraq has WMD and couldn't find any and still no oppology, now India's so called secular state where atrocities against Muslims in Gujrat , Christians in Orrisa and Sikhs in 1984 Khalistan movement is a big slap on this so called secular and non democratic state...it's about time when india should get disintegrated..though hindu zionists are doing their best to create dramas like Mumba 911 and funding terrorists movements like baloch liberation front in Pakistan but still india end is near...I hope after disintegration a pure hindu state emerge that is more peaceful and thoughtful than now..cheers..

Khan, Pakistan - 28 December, 2008

I accept that some political parties in India are indulging in voilent activities to gain mileage. But what pakistan is doing??
Islam has made haram killing of innocent human being are'nt many people killed in pak even after having the knowledge ad wisdom from Allah. Leave aside Indian Hindu outfits they aren't aware of Muhammad (Sal) message they do not beleive in One God. What are Pak muslims doing???? Why are there Shia-Sunni fights?
why pak government is helping America to kill its tribals in western part of pakistan in the name of taliban? Is not our responsibility to educate non beleivers about Allah's message? Why are we bothered about others sins when we ourselves are drowned in sins?

salmantaj, Hungary - 29 December, 2008

missionaries have to pay for the deaths of inncoent and it is they who took lives of people in oriss

india has always been a secular nation...secularism doesnt mean mass conversions... i tell u secularism means living in harmont.. pakistan need not teach india of secularism..we know how minorities in pak and bdesh are persecuted..
the christian missionaries have tied up with maoists to kill hindu saint..hindus have no hate towards minorities...buddhists,jains,zorastrians,jews live in india... they are peaceful and they donot want to destroy the indian culture and they are not attacked.
live and let live... these religions donot do jihad and mass conversions using swords.. more over u cannot just show orissa and say minorities are attacked.. first of all the people who lost their lives in orissa were not christians and they are all hindus. from the past 30 years only 2 people legally converted to christianity. then how can create a huge hue and cry that christians were attacked..
as if the people who got attacked came from italy.. they are locals and they are hindus..
hindu scriptures donot teach jihads and all....christian missionaries and jihadis have killed lakhs and lakhs of people from the past 2000 and 1300 years... nobody has the moral right to teach peace to hinds and indians...

ram, Hungary - 08 January, 2009

sit and introspect

hey man what do u know thats happening in india.. u need not teach india abt secularism and peace..
if there are riots in india today,the blame has to be taken by missionaries themselves,just sit and think ,had there been no missionaries,then there would have been no attacks..iam sure.. these missionaries in the name service come and do business here...these attacks though iam not backing,but they are nothing when they are compared to what missionaries did.. missionaries have killed lakhs across the world mainly aborigines in north south america and australia... i need not say about jihadis,they are still killing thousands in india,when this jihadis kill ,it is just the number of deaths that count,but when hindu groups ,which are mere saving their faith do,then u loudly shout christians are being killed. is that fair on u... i ask u why are not buddists,jains,jews and zorastrians not being targeted in india??? the answer is thet donot hate hinduism being in india.... i know u people are very narrow minded , u will not listen how much ever we say... what do u know abt hinduism ,... nothing...except u developed some stereotypes...hinduism is not single doctrine ..it is rig veda,yajur veda,same veda,atharva veda,upanishads,vedanta,ithihasas etc etc etc... before the birth of islam and christianity hinudu scripts like upanishads said that there is only one god with no form... present day,u people with out knowing anything abt hinduism say that god is not many and god has no form... before ur religion hinduism spoke of one god with no form....u ask why u worship mant gods..thats nothing but personification of one god.. u moreover ask u hindus worship idols..u come to india and c how many idols of jesus are there.. u speak of attacks on minorities..u come and c how many churches are there in india even in the places where there are no christians.. that is our tolerance.. recently ikson temple was demolished in russia.. and that ur intolerance....u keep saying that ur christians think abt ur past...ur ancestors they were worshipping roman gods,greek gods,scanidavian gods...these missionaries and emperor constantine killed many of ur ancestors and even forced ur ancestors to convert ... know ur history and know missionaries and jihads and later speak of minorities in india...dont just read whats said in ur media and come to conclusion.. india has no prob with minorities... but if the minorities keep attacking majority...then we should not act???

ram, Hungary - 08 January, 2009

Food for thought

I don't have to speak a lot about the fallacious and biased comments you've made because there is a lot of comments already.

Just wanted to say one thing. Difference between India and Pakistan-
India : We have a democracy. Leaders are elected. We are not afraid to accept mistakes. Even Mahatma Gandhi, so openly spoke about the 'then' situation in india so freely, and things are moving forward rapidly.

Pakistan- You dont elect your leaders. No freedom of press (Any newspaper which says anything against Islam or Pakistan would be banned). You dont accept your mistakes- identity of the Mumbai blasters an example of this. Known for being aggressive. Have TREMENDOUS problems among minorities - hindus and christians, but it's not covered by the press and not accounted for. Google 'hindus in pakistan' or 'christians in pakistan' and all you see are stories of girls being abducted and forcibly married and converted in their childhood!

What happens in India is what happens in every democratic/ secular country- There are problems, but the press is open, problems surface and problems get solved. 'Problems' are the difference between heaven and earth!

Chaaya, Canada - 10 January, 2009

mr ram

Mr ram it is a pitty that you are justifying killing of innocent Christians by attacking missionaries.
You Indian Hindus have killed and burnt them alive how disgusting.
For your information Christian missionaries are not using any brutal method to convert anyone in India. They are peaceful. If your Hindusim is failed to protect and give equal rights to your own Hindus then it is not fault of missionaries.
Hindusim is based on unequality. Your roten cast syetsm is a shame and blot on face of humanity. Let millions of poor low-cast Hindus to convert to Christianity on their free will. Atleast Christianity gives them equal rights unlikely roten hinduism.
I made myself clear here.
good day

Kerry, Ireland - 10 January, 2009

Example of India's Secularism..

India has proved its secularism on very day when Indians have elected its
*President- A.P.J Kalam (a Muslim)
*Prime Minister- Manmohan Singh (a Sikh)
*Head of ruling Party- Sonia Gandhi (a Christian)
which are three most powerful position inside the country and being a Hindu i have never doubted there intension.
What about you can u accept a Hindu president and Christian PM in your country ?
I think Pakistani's do not love there country because they are more concerned about happenings in India rather than solving its own problem of extremism which is one of the main reason for all the problems around the world.I think Pakistan is the only country which have bought disgrace to Islam for all the bad reasons. According to me no religion is superior and those who think so are the real problem for the world peace.
Also Pakistan needs to understand that there is very little time left with him to prove its innocence by taking some bold steps if it is capable off because if any thing happen again anywhere in the world you can guess who is the real culprit not the lovely people of pakistan but few fundamentalists.
Thanks !




Anubhav, Hungary - 14 January, 2009

Plz speak the truth

All that u say is good in debate.it is not debate here.so plz try to speak the truth.say about the actual face of hinduism,what u say about the hindu mythological books of 'Ramayana'& 'Mahabharata'.I expect that u know about the story of 'Mahabharata'.In that book writer said that v have a hindu country in the world in which there is no place of other religions.your country name 'Bharat' is evolved from that book.

Junaid, Pakistan - 18 January, 2009

Thanks for the in-depth coverage, and especially from someone who isn't even a resident of the country.

I was laughing as I was reading through it all as you 'conveniently' forget to mention violence/provocation from an another religion. Basically what are you trying to project and portray? I mean, seriously..is pakistan that developed a nation that it has nothing to worry about in its own backyard and is constantly interested in state of India. WHat you fail to mention is that those involved in barbarous acts are brought to book and what you fail to explain and what casts a shadow on this trash is that .. the minorities you supposedly believe India has oppressed are the ones representing the nation..

Manmohan sngh - Sikh
Ex -President :APJ Abdul Kalam - President ( 8years)
CUrrent President : Pratibha patil - dalit ...etc

Infact the most popular actor in India too is a muslim - Shahrukh Khan....



Also one more THING! whatever comment I read there will be this comment 'oh india supports/finances/destablishes balochistan ' etc..etc.!WAIT and seriously THINK! If it is TRUE then GIVE PROOF, DONT SPREAD FALSE ACCUSATIONS. If IT WAS TRUE AND PAKISTAN HAD PROOF THEN THEY WOULD HAVE WASTED NO TIME IN CREATING A HUE AND CRY! But they didn't. Know why? Because India isn't invlolved. Its as simple as that. There is a beautiful saying which goes as :- " Don't throw stones at other's houses, especially when your own house is made of glass "

I am beginning to wonder the motive since if you are so panicky over Establishment of democracy then why leave out pakistan where muslims are killing each other or China whose 'freedom' is well known ..but ah how could you possibly say anything about China's human rights , Tibet issue, freedom of speech...
Afterall Democracy ftw!, isn't it?


Ambuj, Hungary - 02 February, 2009

What should Pakistan do?

India is country of terrorist for no doubt.They kill innocent Muslims, Christians, Sikhs and dalits.They also finance and brain wash crazy Afganistan into Pakistan.
Can any explain what is exactly India doing in Afgan-Paksitan border?
Who cares if PM or president or whoever is post in Indian so called secualr country when minorities are treated badly, unbiasdely and beaten , rapped and killed?If PM or President encourage such divide and rule , what is point of being Muslims or Sikn pm or president..hahaha..
There is only one point that is fool entire world that see we have such Muslim president and sikh PM who cant do anything ..hahaha...
My dear all Indians here u people hate Pakistanis but we love innocent Indians who are taken on a ride my clever media+ Politicians....My dear Indian and Hindu friend your country in controlled by elite and rich Zionist.They are the ones who are dividing India so that they keep on ruling people.Get their balls and now cat is leaked out of Bag by Zaid Hamid rebuttal in which is He so beautifully proved that Mumbai was done by such Zionist Hindus with the help of Zionist Jews.So for heaven sake leave Pakistan and let us fight with terrorist in northern areas....
and in case you Indians dont correct ur attitude and Zionist Hindus are not Punished then inshallah that day is not far away when Pakistan will free Dalit, Sikhs, Muslims and Christians of India..
PAksitan army is far far brave and stronger than bloody indian army that is Indian defence Minister has acknowledged that pak has better missile technology and our general just shows Indian army eyes and all ego and war hysteria of Indians and Hindus have melted...

Just ask those turist who have visisted Pakistan and India and they will tell you that Pakistan overall is better, more civilised and developed than India.Indis is nothing but bullshit of Bollywood...
get a life Hindus friends and dont dare talk lies here..

Ahsan, Svalbard And Jan Mayen - 05 February, 2009

CAN WE CONVERT HINDUS INTO TRUE MUSLIMS

I HAVE GONE THROUGH THE COMMENTS OF ALL FREINDS &
WE I HAVE CONCLUDED THAT WHY WE DO NOT DISCUSS KHAWAJA MOIN UDDIN CHISHTI AJMERI, HAZARAT SALEEM CHISHTI, SHEIKH AHMED SARHANDI (MUJADDISDALF-E-ANI) WHOSE MARVELLOUS CHARACHETER AND SINCERETY WITH THEIR ALMIGHTY ALLAH AND HAZARAT MUHAMMAD MUSTAFA SALLAHO ALAIHEWASSALLAM HAD CONVERETED CLANS OF HINDUS AND OTHER NON MUSLIMS INTO A TRUE MULSIMS WITHOUT VIOLENCE.
IT IS CORRECT THAT RSS AND VHP HAS AN UGLY FACE AND THEY ARE BAD SPOT ON THE EARTH BUT IF WE OFFER THEM TRUE ISLAM WITH SINCERITY SUCH AS PRESENTED BY KHWAJA SAHIB AND THEIR COLLEAGUES SO I HOPE THAT THESE VIOLENT HINDU (RSS & VHP) WILL BE CONVERTED INTO TRUE MUSLIMS.... AND IF THE HINDU ZIONIST DO NOT ACCEPT THE ISLAM THEN THEY SHOULD BE READY TO HAZARDOUS DEATH AND IN NEAR FUTURE NO BODY CAN PREVENT THE SAPARATION OF INDIA IN TINY INDEPENDENT STATES.

ON THE OTHER HANDS PAKISTAN WILL REMAIN FOREVER TILL YOM-E-QAYAMAT BECUASE PAK ARMY AND PAK NATION OF PAKISTAN WILL FIGHT IN GHUZVA-E-HIND WHICH WILL BE IN NEAR FUTURE AND ALL TRUE PAKISTANI AND TRUE MUSLIMS ARE READY FOR IT.
THANKS


THANKS
KHALID MUSTAFA


KHALID MUSTAFA, Pakistan - 11 February, 2009

dont believe what you see

The images shown and facts given are both shocking and shameful.But not all of it is true.One should not judge indians by the activities of some of the misguided souls.You are showing the massacare of christians.Do you have pictures of People helping out mother theresa in kolkata or hindus taking shelter in churches after the tsunami...You tell about muslims being raped mercilessly...In pakistan can you say how many oscar winners you have like A.R.Rahman...Even ur nuclear scientist A.Q.khan is under house arrest while in India A.P.J.Abdul kalam was a former president...just as all pakis are not butchers ("like those who killed daniel pearl"),all indians are not radical hindus...may be dats why B.J.P. lost after godhra....and Bala saheb thackrey has shifted gears from hinduism to marathism...Do visit india some time and clear your misconception...You may visit "jama masjid" in delhi,"golden temple"in amritsar,"vaishno devi" in kashnir, and "st.pauls cathedral in kolkata"....I'm pretty confident that you won't find any sikhs muslims or christians or hindus there...you will find INDIANS...May be you will love India a little more then...looking forward to meet you then....JAI HIND...WITH LOVE FROM INDIA...

aruni basu, Hungary - 24 September, 2009

 What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)
Your Comments: *

Your Name:*
E-mail (Optional):
City (Optional):
Country (Optional):
 
 
Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

  Speak Out View All
Military Courts
Imran - Qadri long march
 
Candid Corner
Exclusive by
Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
Suggested Sites