Pakistan News Service

Thursday Jul 18, 2019, Zul-qaadah 15, 1440 Hijri


27 October, 2005

By Umair Khan

  Related News  
Another powerful 7.2-magnitude quake hits Awaran, 22 killed
Earthquake of 4.7 magnitude jolts parts of KP; quake toll hits 400
  Related Articles  
Mass Migration-Apprehensions And Hopes
By Amir Latif
The Quake that could Crack LoC
By Farzana Shah
  Related Speakout  
  More on this View All
  Related News Poll

Spare a scream for the 100,000 dead and 3 million homeless, muted out of world media.

Unmourned by the news media, unmarked by the world, Saturday October 22 was the two week anniversary of the 7.6 magnitude earthquake in Pakistan, India, and Kashmir. An estimated 100,000 have been killed and, of the 3 million made homeless, at least another 100,000 are in high peril as winter rolls down from nearby K-2. If they perish, they would surely have been suffocated by the silent air waves.

For the 3 million homeless the bell tolls noiselessly. Beyond Pakistan`s national news media, their coverage is a silent movie playing out on inside pages (if at all). Four more weeks of radio (and print and TV) silence and the region will become as quiet and stone cold as the news media. The news folks whose attention to the tragedy has declined as swiftly as the deaths have mounted, may finally get to report a "frozen" death toll. In four weeks, winter too will white-out the survivors.

Intense and swift and whole-hearted as the response has been among the compassionate and the aware, it has been far too noiseless. For Pakistanis, for Kashmiris, for South Asians, for Asians, for humans and for humanity everywhere, this is not the time for whispered tears, silent if ardent prayers, mumbled grumblings, and soundless emails.

This is the time to scream.

Not in despair, or panic, or anger. But in recognition and in resonance.

This is the time to broadcast  the unbroadcasted. And this time expires in 4 weeks. There will be little point to being heard after that.

There have been No vigils to mark the disaster: week 1, week 2, now week 3 - I keep counting. No silent, candlelight vigils at sunset. No minute of silence at 8:51am. No day of mourning. No protest march (silent or loud) against NATO`s refusal to airlift the injured. No sit-ins to demand of governments the desperately needed helicopters, tents, medicine, monetary aid. And no demonstrations in front of the oblivious offices of world media.

3 million people have cried out, shouted, groaned, and screamed for 14 days. Cries of pain, of loss and mourning, out of deep rubble, for a sip of clean water, in despair, in panic, in anger. That is a lot of noise muffled down by the media.

These screams must make it through us into radio, TV, online editions and hard copies. Why? Because compassion and humanity do not stifle the cries of the helpless. Villainy and inhumanity do that.

Why else? Because as long as these screams are unheard, they will keep multiplying.

This is the time to scream.

Here is one scream that keeps ricocheting within me. The scream of a boy born the same month and year as my 6 year old son, who was laid out on grass and given candy in place of anesthesia, as one leg is amputated with a non-surgical instrument. Given the 40 or so similar amputations on children each of the last 15 days, there is a scream from a child who was born the very same month and year as your child. If you make his scream heard, it may not multiply.

Why, I wonder, have we not screamed till now. Those for whom the quake struck close to home have responded with unimaginable emotion and effort. I have never seen anything like it within my community. But the din of our passion blocked out the silence around us. That must be why the even the most well-intentioned among us have not reached out to all colleagues, friends, family, schoolmates, neighbors, bystanders, celebrities, talk radio hosts, politicians, journalists. That must be why Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz who met with Angelina Jolie a few months back has not called upon her to raise awareness of the plight of these people. That may be why we have not plastered our local public spaces with flyers and posters. Or called our local TV stations and demanded that they cover the news. Or incessantly called and emailed world governments to send in helicopters. Or protested NATO`s refusal out in the streets. Or bombarded the detached media with voicemails.

But there is still 4 weeks of time left to scream out to the what-you-never-hear-never-exists world. Not just a metaphorical scream but a real one: close your eyes, clasp your hands in font of you,  focus on the unheard scream of a victim, then exhale a loud "Aaaaaaaaaah" till you have no breath left. Smile at the absurdity or cry in relief.

Do this at home, at work, in public places, at non-silent vigils you hold, during commemorative moments of non-silence that you declare, and at rallies you help organize (preferably in front of news media offices). And when others (colleagues, friends, family, schoolmates, neighbors, bystanders, celebrities, talk radio hosts, politicians, journalists) see and hear this, and ask if you are feeling alright, tell them about the earthquake: about the helicopters, the tents, the winter, the 100,000 dead, the 100,000 to save, the 3 million homeless,  the injured, the amputated, the NATO refusal, the silent media.

Tell them about the screams and how to stop them.

Reader Comments:


I,too, hear the silence in my own country and ask why? We have had the tragedy of our own hurricanes, I know. Still why the silence?

Americans are generous, caring people. This makes it even more confusing. The silence of the media.

In the face of all the suffering we see, it is frustrating to only be able to pray and donate. But it is something.

But where is the media? We need them now as never before. The US has its own troubles, yes. But the focus needs to be on Pakistan as well.

We sent them Emails yesterday. Tomorrow we will send more.

The silence has to end.

Isadora, United Kingdom - 28 October, 2005


Pakistan needs to first show the world that it really cares before it asks the world to care. Before asking the world community for money, it should stop the astronomical amounts spent on buying arms. A country that is just about to buy 2 billion dollars worth of F-16s can easily divert the money for quake releif and rehabilitation before demanding money from the west. You cant ask for helicopters from other countries when you have refused the same from your neighbouring countries. Pakistan should first show to the world that they are serious in takling the disaster. It doesnt help that Pakistan has been rated as one of the most corrupt countries in the world. People would not like to see their contrubutions lining the pockets of mullahs and terrorists.

Jacob George, United Arab Emirates - 29 October, 2005

a request

On one side we see musharraf seeking more and more money on the BBC, on the other side relief has not reached to areas even once after 3 weeks (old news).

the way musharraf is seeking money, its easy to understand that most of it will go into fuelling jihadi activities against India and other non-islamic countries.

I will request people to overlook any request for support from Pak establishment, rather they will be better off to support any organisations that are working on the ground to help bereaved people.

Chan, United Kingdom - 01 November, 2005

Militarised Pakistan

A small country like pakistan is spending huge sums of money for military equipments. Pakistan got atomic weapons to protect itself from attack. International community should insist to pakistan that they should divert money to the re construction of quake hit areas.International community should take a decision NOT TO SELL ANY MORE WEAPONS TO PAKISTAN UNTIL THE RE CONSTRUCTION COMPLETE.Pakistan got F16,Crusie missiles,Long range misiles,short range misiles and nearly 500,000 well trained military personel.All these gained at the expense of 85% of poor pakistanis,Whose children got no school to go,no proper hospitals.

Mr. Freedom, United Arab Emirates - 01 November, 2005


Did NATO actually refuse to allow its helicopters to transport the sick and injured?

Ya`akov N. Miles, Canada - 05 November, 2005

easy to criticise

i would just like to comment that its easy to criticise then to come up with some suggestions...
Mr. Omair every body knows that its a grave situation in earth quake hit areas.. but let me that everyone is doing wat every he/she govt and so many NGOs can.. but its not a small thing that has happen... no body can see some dying like that ok..
let me ask wat have u done so far for the victims....????????

nazia, Pakistan - 07 November, 2005


Let me point out one positive thing coming out of this Earthquake. The whole nation is united and determined to set our priorities. Evidently, it seems the struggle is going towards development, which indeed is a positive sign.

Agha, Pakistan - 08 November, 2005


Mr. Miles,

Are you talking to me?

I don't believe I alluded to NATO refusing to help transport the sick and injured in my post. In fact, I wondered about this comment myself when I asked a few other blogs if they would publish this article, in perhaps a naive attempt to somehow keep news of the tragedy out there for what little aid it might garner.

I did research that statement about NATO and could find nothing conclusive.

Perhaps you can do better?

Isadora, United Kingdom - 12 November, 2005

 What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)
Your Comments: *

Your Name:*
E-mail (Optional):
City (Optional):
Country (Optional):
Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

  Speak Out View All
Military Courts
Imran - Qadri long march
Candid Corner
Exclusive by
Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
Suggested Sites