Pakistan News Service

Thursday Nov 15, 2018, Rabi-al-awwal 6, 1440 Hijri

Racial profiling of Arab, Muslim Americans in US media

18 April, 2006

By Ishtiaq Ahmad

  Related News  
Congress nod not needed for Syria attack: Kerry
US to strike Syria without UNSC nod: Obama
  Related Articles  
Who are extremists?
By Afshain Afzal
U.S. Objectives & Middle East Revolts
By Zaheerul Hassan
  More on this View All
  Related News Poll

The process of racial profiling of Arab and Muslim Americans in the US print media was the subject of the inaugural lecture delivered by Suad Joseph on March 22 at the 7th Mediterranean Meeting organized by the Robert Schuman Centre in Florence, Italy.

A world renowned scholar on Muslim women and Islamic cultural studies, Suad is Director of Middle East/ South Asia Studies at University of California Davis, USA, General Editor of Encyclopedia of Women and Islamic Culture, and founder of the American Universities in Cairo and Beirut.

According to her, the Arabs and Muslims in general and Arab and Muslim Americans by association and by direct action have been increasingly racialized and targeted for discriminatory politics and practices in the United States, fueled by the "war on terrorism" media frenzy.

"We live in dangerous times, the media and public authorities drum daily. No threat is more imminent than that of Islam, no site more at risk than the American homeland, and no enemy more fearful than the enemy within, we are told," she said.

The media mantra of the urgent threat of Islam and of the Arabs and Muslims who transport it, according to Suad Joseph, travels through numerous venues. Of particular interest is the manner in which respected print news media increasingly reflect and reproduce racialization of Arab and Muslim Americans and Islam globally. She examined how The New York Times (NYT) and the Wall Street Journal (WSJ), arguably the most influential US newspapers, narrate Arab and Muslim Americans and Islam globally in ways that result from and enable racial policing by associating them with terrorism and a demonized, globalized Islam.

That the NYT is widely considered as a "liberal" newspaper known for advocacy of civil and human rights, makes it a critical site for examining the representation of Arab and Muslim Americans in print media. That the WSJ is considered the leading newspaper for the financial/economic sectors of US society, makes it an additional critical case.

Fuad Joseph's main thesis was that the NYT and WSJ, taken as representational apparatuses, have contributed significantly to the project of racializing Arab and Muslim Americans. While they cannot dictate how their readers consider race, they are representational apparatuses, composite articulations of projects, situated within larger, constantly reconstituted arrays of racial projects and formations. She advanced the following seven arguments in defense of her thesis.

First, the NYT and WSJ represent Arab Americans and Muslim Americans in a manner that mostly operates to differentiate them from other Americans. The ordinariness of and internal differences among Arab Americans and Muslim Americans is at times subtly and at times crassly subverted through a series of direct and indirect associations and representations, the effects of which are to essentialize and racialize Arab Americans and Muslim Americans and represent them in their "collective," essentialized identities, rather than their individualities or differences. Arab Americans an  Muslim Americans are portrayed largely as Muslim, even though the overwhelming majority of Arab Americans were Christian until the 1970's and some scholars argue that Christians are still the majority of Arab Americans.Muslim American are represented as largely Arab, even though Arabs are a minority of Muslims in America and the world. Indeed, the largest grouping of Muslim Americans is African Americans and the

largest grouping of Muslims globally is South Asian.

Second, Arab Americans and Muslim Americans are represented as intimately tied to their countries of origin, perhaps more so that other immigrants and perhaps more tied to their countries of origin than they are to the United States.

Third, Arab Americans and Muslim Americans are represented as highly religious, and perhaps more religious than most Americans. Arab Americans and Muslim Americans are represented as religious devout Muslims.

Forth, devout Muslims are represented as devoted to Islam and other Muslims before they are devoted to the United States and other Americans.

Fifth, Arab Americans and Muslim Americans are represented as linked to international Muslims and Muslim movements, which are themselves racialized as people of colour, dark and dangerous.

Sixth, Muslims around the world are represented primarily in terms of their religious devoutness. That devoutness is represented as being thinly differentiated from religious fanaticism and fanaticism is represented as the character of people who are trained primarily for collective identity rather than for individuality.

Seventh, the "fanaticism" of global Muslims against the United States then becomes a thin veil separating the hearts and heart beats of Arab and Muslim Americans from globalized Islamic fanaticism and terrorism, making Arab Americans and Muslim Americans high risk citizens and subtly justifying indiscriminate violation of their civil rights of, as well as possible violence, against, a vibrant part of the body politic.

To justify each one of the above arguments, Suad prepared a sample database of the news reports and opinion columns dealing with Arab Americans, Muslim Americans and islam in America published in the NYT and WSJ between late 2001 and early 2003. Then under different themes, such as "terrorism" and "policing," she selected some words and phrases. For instance, words such as "terrorist," "terror," "fear," in the case of "terrorism;" and words such as "arrest," "suspect," "security," "deportation" in the case of "policing." Then, in each newspaper's case, the word count was done?to show as to how many times, ranging from a few dozen to a few hundred times, a particular word was used in each news report or opinion column.

Fuad referred to at least a couple of dozens of news stories in the NYT and WSJ, whereby the Muslims apprehended for extremist behaviour or action were actually Pakistanis, but they were depicted as Arabs in both headlines and contents of the news stories.

While Fuad's presentation was applauded, it did receive some criticism from the audience. For instance, she failed to mention that the present process of racial profiling of the immigrants belonging to a particular religious ideology or ethnic background was not occurring for the first time in US history. Likewise, the US citizens of Japanese origin were racially profiled and victimized during the Second World War; or, for that matter, the alleged Communists experienced a similar fate during the 1950's wave of McCarthyism.

Secondly, besides failing to analyze the issue of racial profiling in the US in a historical context, her presentation lacked the comparative perspective. As a participant in the audience asked, if the racial profiling of Muslims or Arabs in the US in the present age of "terrorism" was a reality, then what about widespread racism being practiced against non-Muslims in the Muslim world? A reference was made to an Afghan Muslim who had converted to Christianity but was facing the danger of a death penalty, to prove that the state of non-Muslim minorities in some conservative Muslim countries goes beyond the notion of racial profiling.

As the only Pakistani participant on the occasion, I pointed out a few more flaws in her presentation. First, that she was using essentially a racist argument to condemn racism. Since Islam itself originated from Arabia, the ethnic identity of the Arabs cannot be separated from their religious identity? The same way, it is difficult to separate South Asian Muslims from Middle Eastern Muslims, or Pakistanis from the Arabs, especially in the light of the violent Arabist shift in Pakistan's traditionally pacifist religious creed since the start of the 1970's.



Reader Comments:

Islam is out-of-step with modern times

The problem of Muslims, both men and women, can be summed up in a nut shell: They are out-of-step with the great changes that have taken place around them after the discovery of sea routes. Islam needs period infusion of fresh blood. The Ottoman Turks provided new vitality to Islam after the Fall of Baghdad. The Turks,though a benign rulers, however are known to have closed the medieval trade routes to Western Europe. The fall of the Umyyad Kingdom in Spain and Portugal, spurred the Spanish and Portuguese sailors to brave the oceans and reach the far flung areas of the world. Are our school children taught the story of the discovery of sea routes and its effect on the modern world? Do the multitude of Maulanas and Islamic clerics know of modern history? Pardon me for saying that we Muslims are out-of-step with the chain of events that have left us far behind in the fields of sciences, research, and all branches of knowledge. Islam needs infusion of fresh blood to revitalise Muslims. The futile exercise of blaming the West for Islam's ills should be shed and a more friendlier approach to the West should be adopted.

Sher Mohammad.

Sher Mohammad, Pakistan - 19 April, 2006

Democracy Expenditure Accuracy

Do you approve democracy expenditure layout?

Democracy Compulsion Expenditure IMF Bill
Vs Quran ( this BILL is highly accurate
reliable Democracy)

Quran 2.256 No Compulsion in religion

Iraq Democracy Expenditure Compulsion came
Based on stolen oil so called “we are teaching
Democracy to Iraq Afghanistan Pakistan” in liu
Of oil resource blood organ land hotel apt complex

Modern time's oil based economy medieval Europe
Custom and religion is Democracy expenditure Bill
Some want Muslims to adopt it.

(As anti Allah) They are building foreign owned
Building Apts On IMF Loan Based High Rise Office
Towers Shopping Mall High way Car Traffic
Jam Glass complex Office Building and few
Million High Price Residential Buildings To
Cater Few to Shut their Mouth with Glorified Medieval
Santa Clause Light Gimmick.To achieve this by using
9/11 in UN 178 countries Trying to sell It to local

Waging war ON Allah is death DEMOCRACY
CHAPT 5 ARTICLE 36 i.e. (Quran 5.36).
It is a proof How OIC Muslim wealthy have
Turned Against Quran after buying Cars and
luxury homes for themselves with high commission
revenue insight.

Mohammad(s.a.) “By God,he is not a Believer,by God ,he is
not a Believer,by God,he is not a Believer,with whom His
Neighbours are not Secure.”

benz m Ispahani, India - 21 April, 2006

Racial Profiling in Modern Time Islamic Science

Religious behaviour evolve scientifically based upon
Components such as psycho-biological genes,
Human and Quranic Surah trigger device. The memes
Transmitted is highly scientific computerized phenomenon
Arising out of this world triggering action of intent.
For Believer there is built in protection mechanism...
Consequently the saying you just need to pray “Allah
Show me straight path and do not put me on the path
of those who go astray quoting relevant surah chapt and
Article verse # just like in Court case.
When Muslims are not honest as if they are not practicing
Muslim. The same rule applies to Christians who have fallen
Into clutches of distorted testament wrong priest-church.
Christian Arabs or Jews are few in numbers anywhere.
The leaders of west are really greedy aggressor and follow
Own version of religion or rules of democracy amid
incompetency racism and racial profiling in pursuit to use
It towards OPEC oil OIC resource acquisition.

M.B.Zakaria, United Arab Emirates - 21 April, 2006

 What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)
Your Comments: *

Your Name:*
E-mail (Optional):
City (Optional):
Country (Optional):
Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

  Speak Out View All
Military Courts
Imran - Qadri long march
Candid Corner
Exclusive by
Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
Suggested Sites