Pakistan News Service

Tuesday Mar 26, 2019, Rajab 19, 1440 Hijri

Brain drain a big challenge ahead

20 December, 2005

By M. Abid Rahi

  Related News  
Rehman Malik’s past being whitewashed
Column Of Religion In Passports
  More on this View All

Assured of better reward and security abroad top class professionals,including doctors,engineers, auditors, architects, bankers and commercial pilots have been leaving Pakistan. According to estimates, over two lakh such Pakistanis have left the country during the last one-year only.

The situation should serve as an eye opener for our decision-makers as the people who have the best skills and can provide better services feel insecure in their own country due variety of reasons.

This is not less than a national tragedy as in terms of development we as a nation are passing through a critical phase of history besides the fact that this brain drain could dent our image in the comity of nations.

The professionals leaving the country mostly look for jobs offering attractive salaries abroad, mainly the United States, UK, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, etc.

One thing is abundantly clear that if this huge brain drain continues the ultimate loser will be none other than the common people of Pakistan. The trend of brain drain would serve a severe blow to the overall growth rate that?s why the government and the private sector should join hands to work out modalities to arrest recurrence of such negative trend in the country. The public and private sectors should come up with concrete steps to ensure utilization of these skilled and well-qualified people in the larger national interest.

A survey conducted by the Gallop Pakistan suggested that more than two-thirds of Pakistan?s adult population preferred to go abroad. This is a brain drain with a pain. There is another brain drain ?with shame?. In this situation the brains leaving the country do not want to go abroad out of their own will. Instead, they are forced to leave the country that not only drains Pakistan of valuable minds but also attracts criticism for the government because of its policies.

A segment of society who imposed self-exile upon themselves to ensure protection of their families against excesses meted out to them by the respective governments is a matter of shame for all of us and that amounts to real brain drain.They don?t leave the country in search of better prospects, as the report suggest. They do not run to dodge national tax authorities
. They leave the country because the government miserably failed to measure up to their expectations.

The government needs to take swift but serious decisions with a spirit to implement these to rein in its security agencies and stop harassing the common people as well as persons with high qualifications.

It is on record of the Overseas Employment Corporation that as many as 2,79,021 Pakistanis left the country within a short span of one year. Thousands of other persons, who proceeded abroad for employment through other means, could not be registered.

It is high time to stop the brain drain that could leave us demoralized among the comity of nations. This trend could be arrested only by proper analysis of the framework needed for successful running of academic institutions, identifying areas of weakness, and taking suitable steps to strengthen these areas.

Four basic ingredients needed for smooth and successful operation of public sector academic institutions are faculty, students, infrastructure and administration.

Some of these elements are delicately inter-related. The most important of these elements are faculty and students?if you don?t have high-quality faculty or students, the other two become worthless.

However, excellent infrastructure and able administrators are needed to recruit and retain first class faculty. Quality of students would naturally improve when the other three elements would be in place.

I will not get into the chicken and egg debate of whether high-quality students attract high-quality faculty or vice versa?I have personally seen it work both ways.

In any event, quality of students and infrastructure are not issues at the public sector institutions of higher education because they get the best student intake, primarily due to low tuition fee, and have large campuses and reasonably good buildings thanks to public funds.

The salaries of teaching staff at public sector institutions of higher education are abysmally low. So, faculty members usually take on other part-time jobs and/or run their own businesses to earn extra income. Since this practice has been going on for years, the academics at public sector institutions have deteriorated to a state almost beyond repair.

The only way out of this mess is to significantly enhance salaries of the faculty at public institutions and make them competitive with the private sector institutions. This would result in faculty members making focused effort at their primary jobs and improved academic environment. The "tenure track" and "foreign faculty hiring" schemes offered by the HEC are not solutions to these problems because they are contract based, limited duration appointments.

The other fundamental problem at the public sector institutions of higher education is poor governance. Many of these institutions of higher learning are currently headed by those who have little to do with education, let alone higher education.

Some of the important institutions of education in the country have never been educationists, they don?t know how the mind of a true academician thinks, and they have no clue about managing higher education.

Anything short of implementing these recommendations will result in continued faculty dissatisfaction, leading to further brain drain and lowering of the already dwindling academic standards in our universities.The HEC can play an important role in implementing these proposals. This national body has helped higher education in several areas, but still it can do much more.

A comprehensive strategy on the part of government is needed to convince skilled and well-qualified class to serve the nation and country. In this regard, the government should mull to ensure provision of better facilities, reasonable salaries, creating better job opportunities and jack up their security besides barring the government?s agencies from interfering in the affairs of experts and leading personalities.

Above all, a stable democratic system and proper functioning of national institutions was of utmost importance for the qualified people to stick around and serve their own country to face growing internal and external challenges.


Reader Comments:

Its all in money ..

It seems inevitable, espeically in sub continent b/c of economy but mostly bcuz our own media hypes movie stars, sportsicon and politicians above the best brains which will obviously deprive that special respect (and ego-exercisism associated with high IQs) from our coommunity. Its not that they are earning huge respect aboard but atleast it makes the family here feel proud .. disgusting culture. Also have to blame the education system .. it teaches them to be good employees / to serve others, rather than being good enteprenuers who will eventually help a nation at long run.

Aaron, Hungary - 20 December, 2005

Brain drain

give them resonable wages,respect and above all securty. No one will go.

Anwar, United Arab Emirates - 23 December, 2005

Brain drain from Pakistan ?

brain drain from Pak is kind of unheard of. US H1B program can be a good marker for immigration from a particular country. I have never heard of Pak among the major beneficiary of H1B program.

Chan, United Kingdom - 25 December, 2005

How to reverse the trend for getting brian gains

Pakistan's top priority lies in putting roots to a sound democracy with staying power. The country was founded on a democratic process. Democracy, even, in mediocrity, provides nurseries for nurturing talented leadership and a healthy media.
Let us not forget that one of the best brains in all past history have belonged to the jews. They surpass all humanity in the fields of research, medicine, economics, law, agriculture, sciences and philanthropy. Jews have passed the best part of their exile under Muslim regimes. Turkey stands out as arole model in its treatment to the Christians and Jews. The ruled in Balkans over such countries as Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia, etc that had been Chritian nations with a majority of Christian populations.

Sher Mohammad.

Sher Mohammad, Pakistan - 25 December, 2005


I wonder what the writer means when he says that 'brain drain that could leave us demoralized?'Brain drain has its benefits too ..for eg flow of migrant remittances... bringing of technical know how hopefully at some later stage(remember Qadeer khan although it doesnt has to be as dramatic)...surplus labour both blue collar and white are given opportunites abroad perhaps somewhat easing the pressure in pak, where jobs are scarce to begin with!

faryal, Svalbard And Jan Mayen - 26 December, 2005

Reverse Braindrain

Survival for fittest based upon immigration is called
before hijri mecca surrah after migration medina
surrah resulting in ansar muhajjirin EU canada
immigration law termed it landed immigrant or
illegal pakis or alqaedas or and multiculturism.
Unskilled Pakistanis moved out with rich affluent
skilled muslim leaders.The skilled agha khanis of
Uganda Tanzania and gujrat milawat theme
moved in everywhere .Wars for looting past 100 yrs
of ottoman Turk muslim created Billions of dollars of
Shah and sheik money falling in the hands of european and american.
Alqaeda skull cap madrassa muslim being monitored for radio
active radiation image is none sustainable.
Reverse brain drain with skill and money is the answer.
Consequently came mecca surrah medina surrah
and saddam gumrah gay lesbian legislation as a yardstick
that time is ripe to send blair bush martin Polish Romanian
Spanish and French home.Enough Turks have been eliminated
in 100 yrs.

M.B.Zakaria, United Arab Emirates - 28 December, 2005

 What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)
Your Comments: *

Your Name:*
E-mail (Optional):
City (Optional):
Country (Optional):
Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality. The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.

  Speak Out View All
Military Courts
Imran - Qadri long march
Candid Corner
Exclusive by
Lt. Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd)
Pakistan itself a victim of state-sponsored terrorism: Qamar Bajwa
Should You Try Napping During the Workday?
Suggested Sites